These Ohio Pie Shops Will Turn Your Cold February Days Into Sweet Detours
February in Ohio brings gray skies, biting wind, and the kind of cold that makes staying indoors sound perfectly reasonable. But it also brings the perfect excuse to seek out warm slices of pie in cozy shops scattered across the state.
From Amish Country bakeries to urban pie specialists, Ohio has built a quiet reputation for places that take their crusts seriously and their fillings even more so.
These fifteen shops prove that the coldest month is actually the best time to chase down dessert, one flaky slice at a time.
1. Mama Jo Homestyle Pies, Amherst
Snowy afternoons near Lake Erie feel a lot softer once I see the red sign for Mama Jo Homestyle Pies glowing through the gray. Stepping inside, I always notice how quiet the world suddenly seems, with only the hum of ovens and the low murmur of locals picking up their usual for Sunday dinner.
Fruit pies line the cases in neat rows, from tart cherry to glossy apple, and the cream pies look almost too perfect, with tall whipped clouds and golden crusts that actually taste buttery instead of bland.
I love that this place still feels like a dedicated pie shop, not a side project of a bigger bakery, and you can tell the focus is on doing one thing very well. On a cold February drive, this is where I picture pulling off the highway, picking up a whole pie for later, and sneaking one warm slice in the car before I even reach the next traffic light.
Address: 1969 Cooper Foster Park Rd, Amherst, OH 44001.
2. Gray House Pies, Westlake
Some places feel serious about pie the moment you open the door, and Gray House Pies in Westlake is one of them. I still remember the first time I walked in and saw a handwritten list of flavors that read more like a tiny novel than a menu, with fruit pies, cream pies, and a few savory options quietly stealing the show.
The crust here has that rare balance of flaky and sturdy, so each slice holds together on the fork without falling apart, even when the filling is piled high with berries or apples.
In winter, the shop feels especially comforting, with customers darting in from the cold, grabbing whole pies for family gatherings, and adding just one more slice for the drive home.
On a February road trip around the west side of Cleveland, this is the spot where I would plan a deliberate detour, just to see what seasonal flavor they dreamed up this week.
Address: 26075 Detroit Rd, Westlake, OH 44145.
3. Hartville Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery, Hartville
Some winter escapes start in a parking lot shared with a huge market, and Hartville Kitchen is proof that good pie can anchor an entire day trip.
I like to arrive early enough to wander through the shops, then step into the restaurant side and see the bakery case glowing with cream pies, fruit pies, and seasonal specialties that look ready for a postcard.
The pie list here feels endless, with classic banana, coconut, peanut butter, berry, and more, all made with a kind of calm confidence that comes from baking for decades.
On a cold February day, the dining room fills with families in sweaters, shoppers with bags at their feet, and couples splitting a slice after a late lunch, all of them creating their own small traditions around dessert.
I always tell myself I will just order one slice, then end up taking an entire pie home for later, because walking out empty-handed is almost impossible.
Address: 1015 Edison St NW, Hartville, OH 44632.
4. White House Fruit Farm, Canfield
Cold wind over open fields sets the scene long before I reach the driveway at White House Fruit Farm in Canfield. By the time I park, I am already thinking about what might be in the bakery case, because this place is famous for its doughnuts and pies that pull people in from counties away.
Inside the market, shelves of produce and pantry items frame a bakery where pies share the spotlight with those blueberry doughnuts that visitors talk about for years.
I like how the pies look straightforward at first glance, yet the crust and fillings have that careful balance of sweetness, spice, and texture that only comes from constant practice.
February might not be peak farm season, but it is a perfect time to drive out, pick up a pie, sip something warm, and watch the quiet fields while cars crunch past on the gravel.
Address: 9249 Youngstown–Salem Rd, Canfield, OH 44406.
5. Das Dutch Haus Restaurant, Columbiana
If my winter cravings had a GPS, they would probably route me straight to Das Dutch Haus in Columbiana. The dining room feels warm and steady, with hearty plates coming out of the kitchen and a bakery area that quietly tempts everyone to leave room for dessert.
Here, fruit pies and cream pies sit beside cookies and breads, all baked with the kind of careful consistency that keeps families returning every season.
On a chilly February evening, I like the idea of a slow meal followed by a generous slice of pie, then a box of extra pieces tucked under my arm for the ride home. This is the sort of stop where a simple dessert can stretch a small town visit into something that feels pleasantly unhurried.
Address: 14895 South Ave, Columbiana, OH 44408.
6. Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen, Middlefield
Some places make winter feel slower in the best possible way, and Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen in Middlefield is one of those. When I walk in, I always notice the mix of locals catching up over lunch and visitors quietly studying the bakery cases, trying to decide which pies and breads to take home.
The pies here lean into classic comfort, with fruit and cream varieties that taste familiar without feeling boring, served alongside a full menu of Amish-style meals.
February trips through Geauga County feel more intentional when they include a stop for a hot meal, a slice of pie, and a peek into the gift shop for a small souvenir. It is the sort of place where you linger over dessert, then realize you are already planning the excuse for your next visit.
Address: 14743 N State St, Middlefield, OH 44062.
7. Troyer’s Home Pantry, Apple Creek
Some February mornings in Amish Country start with a faint smell of fresh dough in the air, and Troyer’s Home Pantry in Apple Creek makes that feeling very real. Inside this small bakery, the cases are stacked with pies, breads, rolls, and pastries that locals treat as part of their weekly routine.
The pies have generous fillings and flaky crusts, with fruit flavors that cover everything from tart cherry to rich pecan, plus cream pies for anyone who leans toward silky textures over warm fruit.
I love the idea of passing through on a cold weekday, picking up a slice and a hot drink, and sitting for a moment before the road calls again. Most visitors end up adding an extra whole pie to the order, just to make sure the comfort lasts beyond the drive.
Address: 668 W Main St, Apple Creek, OH 44606.
8. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant, Berlin
Winter in Berlin often looks like a postcard, and Boyd & Wurthmann adds an extra layer of charm with a dessert case that could make anyone reconsider their lunch plans.
This old-fashioned restaurant has been feeding people for generations, and its reputation for serving many different kinds of pie each day is almost legendary in the region.
There is something special about sitting in a simple booth, finishing a plate of homestyle food, and watching servers carry slice after slice of pie past your table on chilly days. When the air outside is cold, and the streets are busy with visitors, a slow dessert here turns a quick stop into a small winter ritual.
I always feel a little smug leaving with a box of extra slices, knowing that the best part of the visit will show up again later that night.
Address: 4819 E Main St, Berlin, OH 44610.
9. Gardner Pie Company Outlet Store, Akron
Finding an outlet store dedicated to pies feels slightly unreal, yet that is exactly what awaits at Gardner Pie Company’s shop in Akron. This is the retail face of a company that has been baking pies for markets and restaurants for decades, and the outlet lets regular pie fans tap into that production in a very direct way.
Freezers and cases hold an impressive range of flavors, from fruit to cream, and it is very easy to overestimate the freezer space at home while loading a cart.
On a cold February afternoon, I like imagining a trip here as a strategic resupply, stocking up on pies that can transform ordinary weeknights into something more celebratory.
It may not have the charm of a tiny farmhouse bakery, but the sheer variety makes this stop a different kind of winter treat.
Address: 191 Logan Pkwy, Akron, OH 44319.
10. Resch’s Bakery, Gahanna
Some bakeries feel woven into local memory, and Resch’s Bakery has that aura, especially now that its newer Gahanna location buzzes with fresh energy.
Inside, the cases overflow with cakes, doughnuts, and pastries, but the pies sit quietly along the lineup, waiting for anyone who still believes dessert should be sliced.
I like that a winter visit can start with a simple plan to grab a few treats and then grow into a whole box that somehow includes a pie for later. In February, when the air outside carries that sharp edge, walking into the warm, sweet-smelling bakery feels like stepping into a small celebration for no special reason at all.
The Gahanna shop makes it easy to turn a mundane errand into a mini road trip with dessert as the destination.
Address: 150 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna, OH 43230.
11. Just Pies, Westerville
Any place bold enough to call itself Just Pies has my full attention before I even open the door. In Westerville, this shop lives up to the name, filling its cases with fruit pies, cream pies, seasonal flavors, and mini versions that make it very hard to pick only one.
I appreciate how direct the whole experience feels; you walk in, you choose a pie or three, and your winter evening instantly looks better.
A cold February drive around the Columbus suburbs becomes an adventure if it includes a stop here, picking up a warm pie for a gathering or a smaller one to share with someone you like spending time with.
There is nothing complicated about it, which is exactly what makes it such a satisfying detour.
Address: 736 Northfield Rd, Westerville, OH 43082.
12. Partial to Pie Bakery, Dayton
When a bakery names itself Partial to Pie, it feels almost rude not to stop, especially on a cold day in Dayton. This cozy spot on Shroyer Road has quickly become known for focusing on pies first, with both classic and creative flavors, plus quiche and other treats that keep the case interesting.
Reviews often mention how welcoming the staff is and how quickly slices disappear once people get them home, which always sounds like the right kind of problem.
In February, I picture grabbing a slice of something warm, settling at a small table, and watching the front door swing open and shut as other people escape the cold for a few minutes. It feels like the kind of place where a simple pie break can reset the whole tone of the day.
Address: 200 Shroyer Rd, Dayton, OH 45419.
13. Mehaffie’s Pies, Dayton
History tastes especially good in February, and Mehaffie’s Pies in Dayton has been perfecting that for nearly a century.
This long-running bakery focuses on pies in a very serious way, offering a full lineup of fruit, berry, and cream varieties, plus cheesecakes and seasonal specials that keep long-time customers curious.
I like the idea of stopping here on a frosty afternoon, picking out a mix of slices, and then realizing there is no realistic way to choose a single favorite. The shop has that comfortable, lived-in feeling of a place that has seen plenty of winters come and go, and somehow that makes the pie taste even more reassuring.
Address: 3013 Linden Ave, Dayton, OH 45410.
14. Bakery Unlimited, Toledo
Toledo has no shortage of bakeries, but Bakery Unlimited on Secor Road keeps appearing in conversations whenever pie comes up. Inside, rows of cakes, doughnuts, breads, and pastries crowd the cases, yet the pies still manage to grab plenty of attention, with fruit and cream options that look ready for any winter table.
I enjoy the idea of stopping here on a gray February morning, grabbing a box with one pie for home and some extra treats for the ride, then watching the city wake up while the car fills with the smell of fresh pastry.
This is one of those places where local reviews talk about staff remembering regulars and special orders, which always makes a bakery feel more inviting.
Address: 4427 Secor Rd, Toledo, OH 43623.
15. Schmucker’s Restaurant, Toledo
Some diners become famous for one thing, and at Schmucker’s in Toledo, pies share top billing with the comfort food. This family-run spot has been serving the city for generations, and even after a kitchen fire forced a temporary closure, they worked their way back to full service while keeping their pie tradition alive.
The dessert case often holds a wide range of options, from fruit to cream, and locals talk about planning visits around their favorite flavors rather than the main course.
On a cold February evening, the glow of the sign on North Reynolds Road feels especially inviting, promising a hot meal followed by a generous slice and the comfortable buzz of a room full of regulars. It is the kind of place where leaving without dessert would feel unreasonably harsh on yourself.
Address: 2103 N Reynolds Rd, Toledo, OH 43615.