This Arizona Cafe Kept Ten Kinds Of Baklava By The Register Before It Closed

Ten kinds of baklava once waited by the register at one small Arizona cafe, right where you paid your bill. That is a dangerous setup for anyone with a sweet tooth.

The kitchen made gyros, chicken shawarma, falafel sandwiches, and Greek fries that people kept coming back for. Some fans returned for more than 15 years.

A little market sat attached to the dining room, too.

Here is the honest part. The original spot closed its doors in December 2024, and I believe it still deserves a proper sendoff.

The family behind it kept cooking at a second location in Gilbert.

I like how a place this small could leave such a big mark on a college neighborhood. So what made it so hard to forget, and where can you still find that flavor today?

A Tiny Mediterranean Spot Steps From Campus

A Tiny Mediterranean Spot Steps From Campus
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

Phoenicia Cafe lived at 616 S Forest Ave in Tempe, Arizona, just a short stroll from the Arizona State University campus. For years, it served Mediterranean food to students, families, and workers grabbing a quick lunch.

The setup was refreshingly simple. You could dine in at a table or grab your order to go.

A small grocery section sat right alongside the dining area. That meant you could finish a shawarma platter and then browse shelves before heading out the door.

Plenty of Tempe restaurants chase trends and flashy decor. Phoenicia Cafe mostly chased flavor, and that focus earned it a loyal following over the years.

The menu leaned a bit Americanized in spots, with burgers sitting beside the kabobs. Still, it kept traditional pairings like hummus, tahini, rice, and warm pita at the heart of the plate.

Its campus location made it a natural stop between classes. Some students even used it as a cozy place to sit, eat, and soak in the neighborhood around them.

Small footprint, big personality. That combination is exactly why the place still gets talked about today.

Why The Tempe Doors Closed In 2024

Why The Tempe Doors Closed In 2024
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

Mid-December 2024 brought news that longtime fans did not want to hear. Phoenicia Cafe closed its Tempe location after a long run, with high rent cited as the reason.

Rising costs have pushed many small Arizona restaurants into tough choices. A family business near a busy university faces especially steep pressure on rent.

That makes this article a little different from a typical restaurant guide. You cannot stop by Forest Avenue for a gyro anymore, and I would never want you to drive there hungry for nothing.

Still, closing one door does not erase years of good meals. Some customers had been eating there for over 15 years, and they described the taste as steady and unchanged.

Consistency like that is rare. Menus shift, cooks come and go, and recipes drift over time.

Phoenicia Cafe somehow held its flavor steady through all of it. That says a lot about the people in the kitchen.

The good news is that the story keeps going. The family continues to run a location in Gilbert, often listed as Phoenicia Grill or Phoenicia Cafe II.

So the flavor did not vanish, it simply moved east.

Gyros And Shawarma Ran The Show Here

Gyros And Shawarma Ran The Show Here
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

Ask what people ordered most, and two words come up fast. Gyros and shawarma were the stars at Phoenicia Cafe.

The gyro pita came stacked with flavorful meat and a creamy tzatziki. Fresh lettuce and tomato rounded it out, which is not a small detail when produce often gets ignored.

Chicken shawarma earned its own fan club. It came as a wrap or as a platter, and the platter was a favorite pick for first-timers.

Newcomers who had never tried shawarma found it an easy introduction to Mediterranean cooking. Friendly servers helped indecisive diners sort through the choices without rushing them.

The gyro pita combo with fries made a solid lunch. Pair it with the house iced tea, and you had a meal that felt like a small reward.

Chicken kabob with rice was another steady choice for regulars. Beef kabob platters, hummus, and tahini also sat on the menu.

Food was made fresh to order, and waits for a meal tended to stay short. For a busy campus crowd, that speed mattered.

Hungry yet? That is the risk of reading about this menu.

Greek Fries Deserved Their Own Fan Club

Greek Fries Deserved Their Own Fan Club
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

French fries are nice. Greek fries at Phoenicia Cafe were the side dish people actually remembered.

The kitchen itself steered guests toward them. When someone mentioned the plain fries needed more flavor, the cafe suggested trying the Greek fries next time.

That tells you where the confidence lived. Flavor and generous size made these fries a standout on the table.

Gyro fries were another fun twist for anyone wanting meat and potatoes in one basket. Crispy fries also came alongside combo meals.

Vegetarians were not left staring at an empty menu either. Many meatless options filled the board, including a veggie platter.

The falafel sandwich stood out as a personal favorite for some longtime customers. One former neighbor made a point of coming back for it while visiting family nearby.

Picky eaters had choices too. Burgers sat on the menu for anyone not ready to try something new.

That mix made Phoenicia Cafe an easy pick for groups. One friend could chase falafel while another grabbed a burger, and nobody had to compromise.

Simple food, done with care. It really can be that straightforward.

The Baklava Case Was Pure Temptation

The Baklava Case Was Pure Temptation
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

Sneaky placement deserves some credit. Around ten kinds of baklava waited near the register, right as you checked out.

Trying to walk past that without buying one took real willpower. Most people did not bother trying.

Pistachio baklava was a highlight. It came with thick layers of pistachio between flaky phyllo, and it clearly tasted house made.

For something extra special, baklava with ice cream was also on offer. Warm, crunchy pastry with cold ice cream is a combination that rarely misses.

Desserts like these turn a quick lunch into a small celebration. They also made a great take-home treat for anyone back at the office or dorm.

Baklava travels well, which made it a perfect impulse buy. A box could easily become a thank-you gift or a late-night study snack.

Plenty of restaurants treat dessert as an afterthought. At Phoenicia Cafe, the sweets felt like a real part of the identity.

Honestly, that case might be the single thing fans miss most. Ten choices at the finish line is a powerful closing move for any meal in Arizona.

A Cozy Room With A Market Next Door

A Cozy Room With A Market Next Door
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

Clean tables, friendly servers, and music playing in the background set a relaxed mood. Phoenicia Cafe felt casual without feeling careless.

The decor drew attention too. Some guests noticed details in the building that echoed the architecture of the mosque next door.

The attached grocery store added a fun bonus. Browsing shelves after a meal made each visit feel like two stops in one.

Service was often described as warm and patient. One server from Tunisia, in particular, became known for her kindness and care.

Families, solo diners, and students all fit comfortably here. The vibe suited a quick bite just as well as a slow lunch with friends.

Out-of-town workers staying nearby also found it handy. On a hot Arizona afternoon, a close walk to good food is a big perk.

One practical note stood out over the years. Bills were totaled at the register, and card payments could carry an added fee, so asking ahead was smart.

Little quirks like that come with many family-run spots. The food and the friendly faces usually made up for it.

Where That Flavor Lives On In Gilbert

Where That Flavor Lives On In Gilbert
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

Missing the Tempe spot? You still have options, and that is genuinely good news.

The same family continues to operate a restaurant in Gilbert, Arizona. It often appears under the name Phoenicia Grill or Phoenicia Cafe II.

Gilbert sits in the East Valley, an easy drive from Tempe for most Phoenix-area residents. That makes it a reasonable trip for anyone craving a familiar gyro.

Hours and menus at any restaurant can change, so checking before you head out is wise. A quick look at current listings can save you a wasted drive.

I cannot promise every dish from Forest Avenue appears on the Gilbert menu. Still, the family connection gives fans a real reason to explore.

Pack a little patience and a big appetite. A new location can feel different at first, even when the recipes share the same roots.

Bringing a friend who loved the old Tempe spot could make it more fun. You can compare notes on the shawarma and argue happily about the baklava.

Sometimes a favorite restaurant does not disappear. It just changes its address and waits for you to catch up.

Small Restaurants Like This One Deserve A Toast

Small Restaurants Like This One Deserve A Toast
© Phoenicia Cafe, Tempe, AZ

Good neighborhood restaurants rarely make headlines while they are open. Often, people only realize their value once the lights go out.

Phoenicia Cafe gave Tempe years of gyros, shawarma, falafel, and stacks of baklava. It also served a home-brewed iced tea with a warm, spiced flavor that some guessed was cardamom.

Little touches like that iced tea built real loyalty. Former locals who moved away even put the cafe near the top of their list when visiting Arizona.

That kind of affection does not come from marketing. It comes from steady food and kind people behind the counter.

So yes, the Tempe doors are closed. The memory still has plenty of flavor left in it.

If this story made you hungry, the Gilbert location is your best next step. Check the details first, then go see what the family is cooking.

And next time you pass a tiny family cafe near you, maybe stop in. Rising rents make every visit count a little more for owners like these.

Tag a friend who still dreams about those Greek fries. They will probably thank you.