This Maine Ice Cream Stand Stays Open Year-Round And Locals Love It For That
When winter settles over Maine and snowbanks grow taller by the day, Fielder’s Choice Ice Cream keeps scooping.
While others close for the season, this local favorite stays open, serving up cones, sundaes, and milkshakes to loyal customers who never lose their taste for something sweet. With multiple locations and a strong following, it’s become a year-round ritual for many Mainers.
The cold never slows things down here, just adds to the charm. At Fielder’s Choice, ice cream isn’t tied to summer. It’s simply part of everyday life.
Open Through Every Season
Most ice cream stands pack it in when autumn arrives, but not this place. Fielder’s Choice proudly serves customers during blizzards, nor’easters, and bone-chilling January nights.
Locals bundle up in their warmest coats and trudge through snowdrifts just to grab their favorite flavors. There’s something wonderfully rebellious about eating ice cream when it’s freezing outside.
The year-round commitment shows real dedication to the community and proves that ice cream season never has to end.
Baseball Theme Runs Deep
From the moment you spot the name, you know baseball matters here. The shop celebrates America’s favorite pastime with clever flavor names and sporty decorations throughout.
Menu items get playful titles inspired by the game, making ordering feel like stepping up to the plate. Walls display baseball memorabilia that gives the space character and charm.
Even folks who never watch a game appreciate the fun atmosphere and creative wordplay behind each offering.
Cash Only Policy
No credit cards, no apps, just good old-fashioned paper money and coins. Fielder’s Choice keeps things simple with their cash-only approach.
Sure, you might need to hit the ATM first, but many customers love this throwback style. It reminds people of simpler times when transactions felt more personal and less digital.
The policy also helps keep prices reasonable since the shop avoids processing fees that other businesses pass along to customers.
Multiple Locations Across Maine
One shop couldn’t contain all the enthusiasm, so Fielder’s Choice expanded to serve more Maine communities. Several locations now dot the state, bringing homemade treats closer to fans everywhere.
Each spot maintains the same quality and friendly service that made the original famous. Whether you live near the coast or inland, chances are decent you’ve got a location within driving distance.
This growth reflects how much Mainers value having reliable access to their favorite frozen desserts.
Generous Portions At Fair Prices
Nobody leaves here feeling shortchanged. Scoops come piled high, often looking comically large compared to what chain shops serve.
My cousin once ordered a small cone and could barely finish it because the serving was so massive. Prices stay reasonable too, which matters when families want treats without breaking the budget.
This combination of value and generosity explains why locals keep coming back season after season, bringing friends and relatives along to share the experience.
Small Batch Homemade Quality
Forget mass-produced tubs shipped from distant factories. Everything here gets made on-site in small batches that guarantee freshness.
This hands-on approach means flavors rotate based on what’s available and what the makers feel inspired to create. You might discover something new each visit, which keeps the menu exciting.
The quality difference is obvious from the first taste, with rich textures and authentic flavors that store-bought brands simply can’t match.
Winter Hours Adjusted But Still Open
Staying open year-round doesn’t mean identical schedules every month. Some locations tweak their hours when temperatures plummet, opening later or closing earlier than summer schedules.
Menus might shrink slightly too, focusing on core favorites rather than offering fifty flavors. But the key promise remains: you can still get ice cream when you want it.
Loyal customers check posted hours and plan accordingly, grateful the option exists at all during Maine’s harshest months.
Family-Run Community Tradition
Corporate chains can’t replicate what happens when families pour their hearts into a business. Fielder’s Choice operates with that personal touch that only comes from genuine care.
Regulars know the staff by name, and employees remember customer preferences without being asked. Kids grow up visiting this place, then bring their own children years later.
That continuity creates something special, a shared tradition that binds the community together one scoop at a time through every season.