This Northern Pennsylvania Pizzeria Hidden In An Ordinary Shopping Plaza Makes Pizza Worth Driving Hours For

The pizza oven here once belonged to the owner’s uncle, who ran a different pizzeria in the exact same spot more than three decades earlier.

Somebody refurbished it, fired it back up, and started turning out charred, crackly pies again.

The gas piping that uncle installed still feeds the kitchen today. I love that kind of detail.

It feels like a family story told through steel and flame.

The dough takes about three days to develop. The menu leans on naturally leavened New Haven-style apizza, which is rare in this corner of Pennsylvania.

There’s even a sourdough Sicilian square and a pie with a sesame seed crust.

All of this sits inside a regular shopping plaza, the kind you’d drive past without a second look. So how does a strip-mall storefront end up worth a road trip?

A Family Story Came Full Circle In This Exact Storefront

A Family Story Came Full Circle In This Exact Storefront
© Gio’s Pizza Co., Clarks Summit 100 Old Lackawanna Trail #12, Clarks Summit, PA

Gio’s Pizza Co. opened in 2022, but its roots in this spot run much deeper. Owner John Thompson’s maternal uncle, John DiLeo, ran Donio’s Pizza right here decades earlier.

That connection is not just a sweet bit of trivia. It shapes nearly everything about the place, from the equipment to the mood on the walls.

The Thompson family, Rick and John, are both from Northeastern Pennsylvania. They didn’t swoop in from a big city with a polished concept and a marketing team.

They came home to a room their own family once filled with the smell of baking dough.

I like how that history gives the pizzeria an honest backbone. Plenty of new restaurants try to manufacture a sense of nostalgia.

This one simply inherited it.

The business uses the tagline “Ancient Methods, New Traditions,” and it fits nicely. The family honors what came before without copying it line for line.

They updated the menu, the dough, and the room while keeping the soul intact.

Clarks Summit remains the original home of Gio’s, but the family has since expanded.

A second location opened in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware, in May 2024, followed by another in Dickson City, Pennsylvania, in July 2025.

That makes the Clarks Summit storefront especially meaningful. It’s where the family’s modern pizza story began, in the same space that connected them to an earlier generation.

The Oven Has A Longer Resume Than Most Chefs

The Oven Has A Longer Resume Than Most Chefs
© Gio’s Pizza Co.

Old ovens tell stories, and this one has plenty. When the Thompsons took over, a Baker’s Pride oven from the Donio’s days was still sitting in the kitchen.

Rather than haul it away, they refurbished it and put it back to work. That’s a bold move for a brand-new business.

It also says a lot about how much they value craftsmanship over shiny gadgets.

The natural gas piping that John DiLeo installed around 30 years earlier is still in use too. So every pie that comes out today gets its heat through the same lines his uncle laid down.

Good luck finding another pizzeria where the plumbing counts as part of the family tree. It’s a quirky detail, sure.

But it adds real weight to the idea of “Ancient Methods” in that tagline.

Deck ovens like this are known for giving pizza a crisp, sturdy bottom. Gio’s leans into that strength by baking pies well-done.

The result is a darker crust that comes out golden brown with some charring at the edges.

Next time you bite into that crackly edge, give a little nod to the oven. It earned its second career.

Framed Headlines Make The Dining Room Feel Like A Time Machine

Framed Headlines Make The Dining Room Feel Like A Time Machine
© Gio’s Pizza Co., Clarks Summit 100 Old Lackawanna Trail #12, Clarks Summit, PA

Clean lines meet old booths in a room that feels both fresh and familiar. The dining area was remodeled with modern decor, yet some original booths from the Donio’s era stayed put.

That mix works surprisingly well. You get a slick, tidy space without losing the comfort of seats that have hosted pizza nights for decades.

Look up at the walls and you’ll spot framed newspaper clippings and old advertisements. They’re meant to carry you back to a different time.

Reading them while you wait is half the fun.

A long galley-style table stretches through the room too. It’s a great setup for bigger groups or anyone who doesn’t mind sharing elbow space with fellow pie lovers.

The overall vibe leans moody rather than bright and cafeteria-like. Some folks love that, and others prefer a classic pizzeria glow.

Either way, it doesn’t look like a typical strip-mall slice shop.

I believe a dining room should match the food’s personality. Here, the room blends history and polish, just like the menu does.

It feels like the past pulled up a chair and decided to stay for dinner.

Three Days Of Patience Go Into Every Crust

Three Days Of Patience Go Into Every Crust
© Gio’s Pizza Co.

Most pizza dough gets made in the morning and baked by dinner. At Gio’s Pizza Co., the dough takes about three days to develop.

That long, slow fermentation includes sourdough elements. The goal is better flavor and easier digestibility.

In plain terms, time does a lot of the heavy lifting that sugar and shortcuts usually handle. The flour is unbleached and unbromated, which matters to people who read labels.

The kitchen also skips blended oils, added sugars, and artificial colorings in its recipes. Instead, it relies on 100% extra virgin olive oil.

Tomatoes are American grown, and the cheeses come from American cows. Those choices sound simple, but they add up.

Quality ingredients have nowhere to hide on a thin, well-done pie.

Even the fresh basil has a local story. The owner has shared that it comes from Kennedy Creek Growers, located just down the road in North Abington.

So when someone calls this pizza worth a long drive, the dough is a big reason.

Three days of waiting on their end means zero waiting on flavor for yours. That’s a trade anyone should happily accept.

New Haven Apizza Shows Up Where You’d Least Expect It

New Haven Apizza Shows Up Where You'd Least Expect It
© Gio’s Pizza Co., Clarks Summit 100 Old Lackawanna Trail #12, Clarks Summit, PA

Connecticut is famous for apizza, so finding a naturally leavened version in northern Pennsylvania feels like a pleasant plot twist. Gio’s makes it a centerpiece of the menu.

The New Haven Apizza keeps things simple with tomato and mozzarella on a thin, charred crust.

That crust has an eggshell texture that cracks and crunches when you bite down. It’s a sound you’ll want to hear again.

Here’s a bragging point worth knowing. John Thompson’s New Haven-style apizza won the “Big Monday” pizza competition, a local showdown in the area.

The sauce gets attention too. It has been described as having a citrus hint, possibly lemon, plus a richness that may come from Romano cheese.

That brightness keeps each slice from feeling heavy.

Prefer something more familiar? A New York-style pie sits on the menu as well, also baked thin and crisp.

Fans of old-school flavor should look for the Old Fashioned tomato pie. It’s a nod to a classic style with roots throughout the region.

I can’t imagine a better way to compare styles than ordering two and splitting them with a friend.

Some Pies Here Break All The Pizza Rules

Some Pies Here Break All The Pizza Rules
© Gio’s Pizza Co.

A cheeseburger pizza with a sesame seed crust sounds like a dare. At Gio’s Pizza Co., it’s a real menu item called Cheeseburger in Paradise.

It piles on burger, cheese, pickles, onions, and a special sauce. The sesame crust gives it that unmistakable bun vibe.

It’s playful without being a gimmick.

Sweet heat fans should look at the Hot Honeybee. It brings pepperoni, hot honey, ricotta, and basil together in one bold combination.

Spicy, creamy, and a little sticky in the best way.

Then there’s the Snow White, a white pie with white truffle cream, ricotta, and mozzarella. No red sauce here, just rich and earthy flavors that feel a bit fancy for a shopping plaza.

Square-pizza lovers get their moment with the Sourdough Sicilian. It’s a long-fermented square pie that uses the same patient dough philosophy as the rest of the lineup.

The fun part is how these creative pies sit right next to the traditional ones. You can go classic, go wild, or do both.

Honestly, the smartest move might be ordering one of each and calling it research.

The Rest Of The Menu Could Carry Its Own Restaurant

The Rest Of The Menu Could Carry Its Own Restaurant
© Gio’s Pizza Co., Clarks Summit 100 Old Lackawanna Trail #12, Clarks Summit, PA

Pizza gets the headlines, but skipping everything else would be a mistake. The menu reaches deep into Italian-American comfort food.

Ribeye cheesesteaks sit alongside chicken parmesan sandwiches and house-made meatballs. There’s Cacio e Pepe Mac and Cheese for anyone who likes their pasta extra cozy.

Soup lovers can warm up with Pastina, a comforting combination of pasta, carrots, chicken broth, and Parmesan cheese.

On a cold Pennsylvania evening, that kind of bowl sounds like a warm blanket you can eat.

Wings and chicken tenders cover the crowd that just wants something familiar. The Hot Chicken Box adds fries, pickles, and flavorful sauces for a heartier meal.

Sandwich fans have more choices too. Sausage and peppers, meatball heroes, and chicken parmesan offer plenty of ways to enjoy Italian-American favorites without ordering a pizza.

Pasta dishes include Spicy Vodka Sausage, Chicken Marsala, and pasta with meatballs. The kitchen uses bronze-die pasta, which gives the noodles a texture that holds sauce beautifully.

Save room for dessert, because the sweet side has its own appeal. New York-style cannoli and sourdough cookie bars offer a satisfying finish.

The kitchen has also experimented with creative seasonal treats. Specials can change, so checking the latest offerings before you visit is a good idea.

All of this makes Gio’s a smart pick for groups with mixed cravings. Pizza might bring everyone through the door, but the rest of the menu gives them plenty of reasons to stay.

Watching Your Pie Come Together Is Part Of The Show

Watching Your Pie Come Together Is Part Of The Show
© Gio’s Pizza Co.

Forget the idea of food vanishing behind a swinging kitchen door. The owners describe Gio’s as an interactive experience where pizza gets assembled and built right in front of you.

That setup means there’s no official table service. You order at the counter, and the team stays focused on getting the food right.

It’s a choice that puts the pizza first.

Dine-in, take-out, and delivery are all available. So whether you want the full atmosphere or a box on your couch, there’s a path to your slice.

Timing matters, though. Gio’s is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, and weekday hours begin in the late afternoon.

Weekend hours start earlier in the day.

Since schedules can shift, double-checking the hours before a long drive is a wise habit. Nothing stings like arriving hungry to a dark storefront.

Friday evenings can get busy, so ordering ahead is a good plan for take-out. Patience pays off here, much like it does with the dough.

I like that the experience feels hands-on and personal. You aren’t just buying dinner.

You’re watching a craft happen a few feet away.

Your GPS Will Lead You Past A Grocery Store To Greatness

Your GPS Will Lead You Past A Grocery Store To Greatness
© Gio’s Pizza Co., Clarks Summit 100 Old Lackawanna Trail #12, Clarks Summit, PA

Grab your keys and set the map to 100 Old Lackawanna Trail #12, Clarks Summit, PA 18411. That’s where Gio’s Pizza Co. waits inside a shopping plaza.

The center is known locally as Gerrity’s Plaza or Summit Square Shopping Center. It’s the kind of spot you’d normally visit for errands, not a pizza pilgrimage.

That ordinary setting is part of the charm. There’s no grand entrance or fancy sign shouting for attention.

The surprise comes once the food hits the table.

Clarks Summit sits just north of Scranton in Northeastern Pennsylvania. That makes it an easy stop for anyone traveling through Lackawanna County or exploring the region.

Plaza parking is usually a perk too. You won’t circle city blocks hunting for a spot while your stomach complains.

Plan your trip around the hours, then give yourself time to linger. Read the framed clippings, slide into a vintage booth, and watch the crew stretch dough.

A strip-mall storefront rarely becomes a destination in Pennsylvania.

This one pulls it off with family history, patient dough, and a well-loved oven. Some drives end at landmarks, and this one ends with a crackly slice.