This Ohio Pie Outlet Is Taking Thanksgiving Orders For Dozens Of Homemade Favorites

One family bakery turns out more than 60 pie varieties, and its outlet store takes Thanksgiving orders by the boxful. Online orders can hold up to 40 pies before you even need to call.

That bakery has been family-owned and operated since 1945. Over eight decades, it has grown into a major Ohio pie producer while keeping its roots in the Akron area.

The holiday lineup reads like a dream dessert table. Pumpkin, pecan, mince, sweet potato, apple, and tall meringue pies all share the list.

The company also makes unbaked pies for wholesale customers, although availability at the public outlet can differ. That gives retailers another way to offer fresh-from-the-oven desserts.

I appreciate a bakery that supplies pies to stores across the country but still keeps a door open for neighbors. For me, that sounds like a good reason to plan dessert early.

Your Thanksgiving Dessert Plan Can Be Settled Weeks Early

Gardner Pie Company makes holiday dessert planning almost suspiciously easy. Its outlet store in Akron takes Thanksgiving orders online, so you can lock in pies before the grocery rush begins.

The online system lets you order up to 40 pies at once. Need more than that for a church dinner or a giant family reunion?

You’ll need to call the store directly.

Timing matters here, because the order window closes about a week before the holiday. Pickup happens on the two days right before Thanksgiving, which keeps every pie fresh for the big table.

Payment works the old-fashioned way. You pay at the store when you collect your order, since online payment isn’t part of the setup.

Delivery isn’t offered either, so someone in the family gets a pie-fetching mission. Honestly, that job comes with the best perks of the whole holiday week.

Holiday pies are in high demand, so ordering ahead is the smart play. Waiting until the last minute is a risky way to treat your favorite pumpkin pie.

My advice is simple. Pick your flavors early, mark your pickup day, and enjoy being the most organized relative at dinner.

Every Classic Holiday Pie Shows Up To The Party

Pumpkin gets the spotlight every November, and it absolutely belongs on this menu. Right beside it sit pecan, mince, apple, and cherry, the dessert lineup most families expect to see.

Sweet potato pie is here too. So is Sweet Potato Crunch, a fun twist for anyone who likes a little texture with their spice.

Mince pie deserves a special shout-out. Plenty of bakeries skip it, so finding one ready for Thanksgiving feels like a small family tradition rescued.

The beauty of this list is how easily it covers everybody. Grandpa can have his pecan, while the kids argue over the last slice of apple.

Apple fans get options, too. Apple Crisp, Apple Walnut, and Honey Crisp Apple all join the regular apple pie on the full menu.

With more than 60 varieties in production, you could build a dessert table that looks like a bakery case. Choosing just two might be the hardest decision of your entire holiday.

A good strategy is to mix one classic with one surprise. That way tradition stays happy, and someone still gets to say they tried something new this year.

Fruit Lovers Get A Seriously Colorful Lineup

Four berries in one pie sounds like a bold move. The Very Berry blends strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, and red raspberries into one deep, jewel-toned filling.

Fruit pies are clearly a strength at Gardner Pie Company. Peach, Blackberry, and Strawberry Rhubarb all bring that summer-orchard feeling to a chilly November table.

Peach fans should pay extra attention. Peach Praline and Peach Melba are available for Thanksgiving preorders, while Churro Peach appears in the company’s broader flavor collection.

Churro Peach is the playful one. It pairs sweet peaches with a cinnamon sugar crumb topping, which feels like a carnival snack wearing its holiday best.

Pineapple Upside Down shows up as a pie as well. It borrows a classic cake idea and moves it into a crust, which is pretty clever.

Blueberry Lemon Buckle adds a bright citrus note to the mix. After a heavy turkey dinner, a tangy fruit slice can feel downright refreshing.

Not everyone at the table wants pumpkin, and that’s fine. A fruit pie or two gives your guests a cheerful, colorful choice beside the spice-heavy classics.

Cream Pie Fans Should Claim Their Slice Fast

Tall meringue peaks are able to stop conversation, at least for a second. Lemon Meringue and Coconut Meringue both bring that dramatic, toasty-topped look to the dessert table.

Gardner Pie Company also offers a smooth lineup of cream pies. Chocolate Cream, Banana Cream, and Butterscotch Cream cover the cozy, nostalgic side of dessert.

Then there’s Peanut Butter Cream. It’s the kind of pie that turns a quiet relative into someone suddenly very interested in seconds.

Cream pies make a smart pairing with baked fruit pies. One feels light and silky, while the other brings warm spice and juicy filling.

Butterscotch Cream deserves a little extra love. It’s an old-school flavor that doesn’t show up on many modern menus anymore.

These are great choices for the guest who skips pumpkin every year. Every family has one, and now that person has plenty of happy options.

Plan your fridge space before pickup day, though. Cream pies need a cool spot, and Thanksgiving refrigerators are famously crowded with leftovers waiting their turn.

Bake It Yourself Or Let The Pros Handle It

Here’s a clever twist most pie shops don’t offer. Gardner Pie Company produces unbaked, frozen, and prebaked pies for wholesale customers, while its public outlet primarily sells baked and frozen baked pies.

Unbaked pies are perfect for anyone who loves that fresh-from-the-oven smell. However, shoppers should check with the outlet before assuming a particular unbaked variety is available.

Already-baked pies are the easy route. Grab them, bring them home, and slice when the turkey plates are cleared.

Sizes vary too, which helps with planning. The bakery produces pies in 8, 9, and 10-inch options, while its Thanksgiving preorder menu primarily features 9 and 10-inch pies.

A 9-inch pie is handy for a smaller gathering. The bigger sizes make more sense when cousins, neighbors, and surprise guests all show up.

Freezing ahead is another tactic worth considering. Just check the storage and preparation instructions for your chosen pie before making room in the freezer.

Not sure which style fits your crew? Ask the outlet staff when you order, since they handle these questions every holiday season.

A Pie Story That Started Back In The 1945

Long before online pie orders existed, Gardner Pie Company was making a name for itself in Northeast Ohio. The business traces its official beginnings to 1945.

Historical records show the company operating in Barberton during the 1950s.

Over the following decades, the pie-focused business expanded while keeping its connection to the region.

Gardner Pie Company has been family-owned and operated since 1945. That’s eight decades of one family keeping Ohio stocked with crusts and fillings.

The company later settled into its current Akron home. Today it works as a national supplier to retail markets, restaurants, farm markets, and distributors.

That means you may have eaten one of these pies without knowing it. They travel well beyond the outlet store doors into stores and restaurants.

I find that history comforting during the holidays. A family business with deep local roots fits naturally with a meal built around family traditions.

So when you set a slice on the table, there’s a bit of a story attached. It’s a nice detail to share when someone asks where dessert came from.

The Outlet Store Is Where The Magic Meets Your Hands

A national pie supplier with its own neighborhood shop sounds almost too convenient. Yet that’s exactly what the outlet store at 191 Logan Pkwy, Akron, OH 44319 offers.

The building sits in the Portage Lakes area on the south side of Akron. It’s a working bakery operation, so think pie pickup spot rather than cafe hangout.

There’s no dine-in setup here. You come, collect your pies, and take the goodness home to your own table.

For Thanksgiving, customers choose a pickup window when placing their orders online. Pies must be collected at the outlet on November 24 or 25, between 8 AM and 4 PM.

The store stays closed on Sundays. Regular hours are Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 4 PM and Saturday from 8 AM to noon.

Selection in the case can change from day to day. Following the bakery’s Facebook page helps you see what’s ready before you make the drive.

For holiday orders, though, the online system removes the guesswork. Your pies wait for you, boxed and ready, on your chosen pickup day.

Good Ingredients And A Shelf Of Local Honors

Real sugar goes into these pies, whether from cane or beets, along with quality spices. That’s a clear sign the bakery cares about what fills each crust.

The pies are kosher-dairy, which matters to plenty of families. They also contain 0g trans-fat per serving, a nice bonus for label readers.

Quality standards add to the appeal. Gardner Pie Company emphasizes real fruit, small-batch dough preparation, and its signature flaky crust.

The bakery also maintains food safety procedures for its large-scale production. Its published manufacturing information describes inspections and protective packaging.

The bakery has appeared in the Ohio Proud member directory as well. That program highlights products made or grown right here in the state.

Trust shows up in another way, too. The company has held Better Business Bureau accreditation since 2001 and carries an A+ rating.

None of this replaces your own taste test, of course. Still, it’s reassuring to know your holiday dessert comes from a place with real credentials and serious standards.

Smart Timing Makes Pickup Day A Breeze

Weekday mornings can be a practical time to visit the outlet. With the daily selection changing, arriving early may give you a better chance of finding the flavors you want.

Pies often sell out, especially popular flavors. Arriving early or ordering ahead gives you the best shot at your favorites.

Savory vegetable pies sometimes appear at the outlet too. However, these are not listed among the current Thanksgiving preorder selections, so check availability before planning dinner around them.

Budget-minded shoppers can look at the Delightful line. These classic fruit pies have a slightly thinner fruit layer and focus on value.

Bring something sturdy for transport. A flat trunk space or a laundry basket keeps boxes steady, because nobody wants a pecan pie sliding around corners.

Keep your order details handy when you arrive. Since payment happens at pickup, having everything ready speeds up the visit for you and the staff.

Gardner Pie Company makes the hardest part of Thanksgiving dessert surprisingly simple. Order early, pick up on time, and let this Ohio bakery handle the crust while you take the compliments.