This Pennsylvania Bakery Will Transform Your Cinnamon Roll Expectations This March
March mornings in Pennsylvania feel better when they start with something warm, sweet, and unapologetically indulgent.
Open the bakery door and the scent of cinnamon, brown sugar, and fresh dough rolls over you like a cozy invitation.
Trays of sticky spirals gleam under soft lights, icing melting into every curve, caramel bubbling at the edges. Call it swirl satisfaction, sticky sweet perfection, a breakfast that doubles as dessert.
Cinnamon rolls may seem simple, yet when the layers are soft enough to pull apart with your fingers and the glaze seeps into every bite, they become unforgettable.
Bakeries know how to do comfort, but this spot raises the bar with rolls that practically demand a fork and a moment of silence in Pennsylvania.
I once grabbed one on a whim before a road trip, thinking I would nibble as I drove.
Instead, I pulled over halfway down the block just to finish it properly, laughing at how quickly my expectations had been completely rewritten.
Quick Snapshot: Everything You Need to Know Before You Go
Name: Mr. Sticky’s
Type: Bakery specializing in sticky buns and cinnamon rolls
Setting: Cozy, no-frills counter-service spot set behind the Golden Plaza shopping center
Location: 1948 East 3rd Street, Williamsport, Pennsylvania 17701, located behind the Xfinity store on 3rd Street
Arrival Tip: The bakery can be tricky to find on your first visit since it sits off the main road. Drive around to the back of the plaza and look for the drive-through window.
Arriving early is strongly recommended.
Portions: Generously sized buns that are easily shareable, sold by the single, half dozen, or full dozen
Hours: Monday through Saturday, 6 AM to 2 PM. Drive-thru buns run 2 to 4.
Sunday closed.
Price Range: Budget-friendly, around $2 per sticky bun
Website: mrstickys.net
Why This Place Is Worth The Drive
Some bakeries are worth a short detour. Mr. Sticky’s is worth rearranging your entire Saturday.
Reviewers have driven close to four hours specifically to pick up a dozen sticky buns, and multiple customers from Long Island make it a regular stop during cabin trips to the Williamsport area. That kind of loyalty does not happen by accident.
The bakery has been operating since 2000, and in that time it has built a reputation that stretches well beyond central Pennsylvania.
Customers from across the state and the country have discovered it through fairs, word of mouth, and online orders.
One retired customer described their sticky buns as easily 100 percent better than any similar product he had tried elsewhere.
Best For: Road trippers, weekend adventurers, and anyone who takes baked goods seriously.
Insider Tip: Call ahead to pre-order your dozen, especially on weekends, so you are not caught empty-handed if they sell out early.
The Cinnamon Roll Is Absolutely Perfect
Forget everything a grocery store cinnamon roll has taught you. The rolls at Mr. Sticky’s are baked from scratch every single morning, and the difference is immediate the moment you lift one out of the box.
Soft, chewy, and generously sized, each roll carries a warm cinnamon flavor that does not feel artificially sweetened or overpowering.
One longtime customer put it simply: these are pure pleasure. The icing arrives in a separate container, which means you control how much goes on top.
Heat the bun in the microwave for about 20 seconds, add your icing, and you have a bakery-fresh experience right at home.
Quick Verdict: Pro Tip: Genuinely one of the best cinnamon rolls available in Pennsylvania, full stop. Ask for the cream cheese icing option.
Multiple reviewers specifically called it out as a crowd favorite, and it pairs beautifully with the warm, chewy roll without making things too sweet.
Five Bun Varieties That Cover Every Craving
Mr. Sticky’s keeps the menu focused and intentional. Rather than offering dozens of options that dilute quality, they make exactly five versions of their signature buns and rolls.
That kind of restraint signals real confidence in the product, and regulars will tell you every single variety earns its place on the menu.
The lineup includes the original Mr. Sticky bun, a plain cinnamon roll, a walnut sticky bun, a peanut butter cinnamon roll, and a cream cheese cinnamon roll. Each one has its own personality.
The walnut sticky bun brings a satisfying crunch, while the peanut butter cinnamon roll delivers a fluffy, nutty sweetness that one reviewer called absolutely no joke.
Why It Matters: A short, well-executed menu almost always beats a long, inconsistent one. Every item here is made with the same care and attention, which is exactly why customers keep coming back for more than one variety per visit.
The Sticky Bun Itself Has A Signature Move
Here is the detail that separates a Mr. Sticky’s bun from everything else you have eaten. After baking, the rolls are flipped once they come out of the oven.
The brown sugar mixture that sits at the bottom of the pan during baking melts into a smooth, silky cap that coats the top of each finished bun. It is a small technical step that creates a dramatically different result.
That caramelized crown is not sticky in an unpleasant way. It sets into a glossy, slightly crisp shell that gives way to soft, chewy dough underneath.
The contrast in texture is what makes the first bite genuinely surprising, even if you have been eating cinnamon rolls your whole life.
This flipping technique is a classic sticky bun tradition, but very few modern bakeries still execute it consistently.
At Mr. Sticky’s, it has been the standard since the start in 2000 and shows no signs of changing anytime soon.
Finding The Bakery Is Part Of The Adventure
Getting to Mr. Sticky’s for the first time feels a little like following a treasure map. The bakery sits behind the Golden Plaza shopping center on East 3rd Street in Williamsport, Pennsylvania, set behind the Xfinity store.
If you are looking for a prominent street-facing sign, you might drive past it twice before realizing where to turn.
Head around to the back of the plaza and you will find the drive-through window along with a small walk-in entrance.
Regulars navigate it without thinking twice, but first-timers should use the full address, 1948 East 3rd Street, Williamsport, Pennsylvania 17701, and trust their GPS to get them there.
The posted hours also list drive-thru buns from 2 to 4, until sold out, so late afternoon visitors can still snag buns if supplies hold.
Check the hours before you go. The bakery operates Monday through Saturday from 6 AM to 2 PM, with drive-thru buns 2 to 4, and is closed Sundays.
Arriving before 10 AM gives you the best chance of catching fresh-from-the-oven buns.
The Peanut Butter Icing Deserves Its Own Fan Club
If you have never had peanut butter icing on a warm cinnamon roll, consider this your official introduction.
The peanut butter cinnamon roll at Mr. Sticky’s has developed a devoted following, and the icing is the main reason why.
It is perfectly sweet without being cloying, and the texture lands somewhere between creamy and fluffy in a way that feels genuinely indulgent.
One reviewer put it plainly: come for the sticky buns, stay for the peanut butter cinnamon rolls. That is not hyperbole.
The flavor combination works because the nuttiness of the icing balances the warm spice of the cinnamon without competing with it. Each bite feels intentional rather than accidental.
Who This Is For: Common Mistake to Avoid: Anyone who grew up eating peanut butter straight from the jar will feel an immediate connection to this roll. Do not assume the peanut butter icing is heavy or dense.
It is lighter than expected and pairs surprisingly well with a strong cup of coffee on a cold March morning.
Beyond The Buns: A Full Breakfast and Lunch Menu Awaits
Most people show up at Mr. Sticky’s for the buns, which is completely understandable. But walking out without checking the rest of the menu means missing out on some genuinely solid food.
The bakery serves homemade soups, fresh salads, and sandwiches built on their own housemade rolls, which are baked with the same daily care as the sticky buns.
The chicken sandwich has earned its own loyal fans. One reviewer described it as crispy, juicy, and packed full of flavor, which is exactly what you want from a bakery that clearly takes its bread seriously.
The chicken bacon ranch sandwich has also been called out specifically by name in multiple reviews, alongside iced coffees that round out the lunch offering nicely.
Best For: Lunch visitors who want more than just a sweet treat to take home.
You Can Order Mr. Sticky’s Buns From Anywhere In The U.S.
Living far from Williamsport is no longer a valid excuse for missing out. Mr. Sticky’s ships their sticky buns across the entire country, which means anyone with a mailing address and a serious sweet tooth can place an order.
The process starts with a phone call to Marcy directly at +1 570-772-8258, where the team walks you through your options and helps you pick a shipping day that works.
Orders ship via FedEx Home Delivery, Ground. One reviewer who sent a dozen as a birthday gift described the process as seamless and praised the staff member who handled the order by name.
The buns freeze exceptionally well, and with the right reheating method, they taste remarkably close to fresh from the oven.
Pro Tip: Wrap each bun individually in plastic wrap, then place them in airtight ziplock bags with the air squeezed out.
Defrost overnight in the fridge, let them sit at room temperature for a bit, then warm in a toaster oven for about ten minutes for best results.
The Pricing Makes It Even Harder To Say No
At roughly two dollars per sticky bun, Mr. Sticky’s offers one of the most reasonable pricing structures you will find at a specialty bakery anywhere in Pennsylvania.
A full dozen comes in around the $24 range for regular sticky buns, though pricing for specialty varieties may vary slightly. Shipping pricing lists $24 per dozen regular and $28 per dozen walnut buns.
The value becomes even more obvious when you factor in the size of each bun. These are not dainty pastry shop portions.
They are large, shareable, and filling enough that one bun can reasonably be split between two people, especially if you are pairing it with coffee or a sandwich from the lunch menu.
Why It Matters: Great food at a fair price builds real community loyalty.
The fact that Mr. Sticky’s has maintained affordable pricing since 2000 while keeping quality high is genuinely impressive and worth recognizing.
Pre-Ordering Is The Smart Move, Especially On Busy Days
Walking in without a pre-order on a busy Saturday morning is a gamble that does not always pay off. Mr. Sticky’s bakes fresh every day, which means supply is genuinely limited.
On high-volume days, including fundraiser orders and local event rushes, the bakery has been known to run out of sticky buns and cinnamon rolls before noon.
A few reviewers discovered this the hard way after waiting in line. The good news is that calling ahead is easy and the staff is consistently described as patient, helpful, and friendly.
One reviewer specifically praised the experience of placing a phone order as smooth and enjoyable, which says a lot about the customer service culture at this small Pennsylvania bakery.
Marcy, on the shipping line, has been mentioned by name in multiple glowing reviews for her warmth and attentiveness.
Final Verdict: Key Takeaways Before You Plan Your Visit
Mr. Sticky’s in Williamsport is a must-visit destination for anyone with a serious sweet tooth.
Located just off the main strip behind the Xfinity building, this bakery has been specializing in homemade sticky buns since opening its doors in the early 2000s.
The sticky buns are the star attraction here, with several varieties including original, walnut, and cinnamon buns topped with cream cheese or peanut butter icing.
Many locals and visitors make intentional trips just for these treats, often arriving early before the most popular types sell out.
In addition to its signature buns, Mr. Sticky’s offers a full menu of sandwiches, soups, salads, and coffee, making it a solid breakfast or lunch stop.
There’s indoor seating and a convenient drive-thru window, and its welcoming atmosphere keeps customers coming back again and again.
Whether you’re stopping by while passing through or planning a dedicated visit, the gooey, fresh-baked sticky buns at Mr. Sticky’s are an experience that many say is worth the trip.