Top Spots For Fresh Seafood In Sebastian, Florida
Sebastian, Florida, sits along the Indian River Lagoon like a hidden treasure chest overflowing with oceanic delights.
This charming coastal town has earned its reputation as a seafood lover’s paradise, where the catch of the day isn’t just a menu item, it’s a way of life.
Whether you’re craving succulent shrimp, buttery lobster, or fish so fresh it practically swam onto your plate, Sebastian delivers flavor-packed experiences that’ll make your taste buds do the happy dance.
Get ready to explore the most fin-tastic dining destinations this waterfront wonderland has to offer!
1. Sebastian Saltwater Marina Restaurant
Perched right on the edge of the Indian River, this marina gem serves up views that compete with the incredible food for your attention.
Sebastian Saltwater Marina Restaurant combines the relaxed vibe of a working marina with serious culinary chops that’ll impress even the pickiest seafood snobs. The smell of salt air mixes with sizzling garlic butter, creating an aromatic experience that starts before you even sit down.
Their menu reads like a love letter to the ocean, featuring everything from grouper sandwiches to crab cakes that crunch on the outside and melt on the inside. Locals swear by their fish tacos, which pack enough flavor to make you forget you’re eating something technically healthy.
The casual atmosphere means you can show up in flip-flops and nobody bats an eye—this is Florida living at its finest. Watching boats glide by while munching on coconut shrimp feels like vacation mode, even if you’re just grabbing lunch on a Tuesday.
Families love the kid-friendly menu and outdoor seating, where little ones can watch pelicans dive-bomb for their own seafood dinners. Service hits that sweet spot between attentive and laid-back, letting you enjoy your meal without feeling rushed.
Location: 1732 Indian River Dr, Sebastian, FL 32958
2. Mo-Bay Grill
Caribbean vibes meet Florida fresh at this tropical-themed hotspot that transports your taste buds straight to island paradise.
Mo-Bay Grill doesn’t just serve seafood—it throws a flavor party where jerk seasoning, mango salsa, and perfectly grilled fish dance together in delicious harmony. The name hints at Montego Bay, and the kitchen delivers on that promise with spice blends that wake up your palate without setting your mouth on fire.
Their blackened mahi-mahi practically melts off the fork, while the conch fritters deliver that perfect combination of tender seafood wrapped in crispy, golden perfection. Waterfront seating is not directly on the river here, but nearby views and outdoor tables still let you enjoy Sebastian’s breezes while working through a plate of peel-and-eat shrimp that arrives steaming hot.
Sunset dining here feels downright magical, with the sky painting itself in oranges and pinks while you savor every last bite.
Staff members bring genuine warmth to every interaction, making recommendations like they’re sharing family secrets. Whether you’re celebrating something special or just treating yourself to a Tuesday night feast, Mo-Bay delivers memorable moments alongside exceptional seafood.
Location: 1401 Indian River Dr, Sebastian, FL 32958
3. The Crab Stop of Sebastian
Sometimes the best seafood experiences happen at places that look unassuming from the outside but pack serious flavor firepower within.
The Crab Stop of Sebastian understands that when you’re craving crustaceans, fancy tablecloths and stuffy atmospheres just get in the way of good eating. This no-frills spot focuses all its energy on what matters most: delivering crab dishes that’ll have you cracking shells and grinning from ear to ear.
Their snow crab legs arrive by the pound, steaming and ready for you to dig in with bibs, butter, and zero judgment about messy fingers. Stone crab claws during season taste like the ocean decided to give you a gift, sweet and succulent with that signature firm texture.
Beyond crab specialties, the menu features shrimp prepared every which way—boiled, fried, grilled, and in hearty seafood combos rather than heavier pasta dishes that stick to your ribs in the best possible way. Portions lean toward generous, meaning you’ll likely have tomorrow’s lunch sorted before you finish tonight’s dinner.
Prices stay reasonable despite the quality, making this a spot you can visit regularly without emptying your wallet. The casual, come-as-you-are vibe attracts everyone from construction workers on lunch breaks to families celebrating birthdays with seafood feasts.
Location: 1550 Indian River Dr, Sebastian, FL 32958
4. Squid Lips Overwater Grill
Built literally over the water on sturdy pilings, this Sebastian institution lets you dine so close to the river you could practically high-five passing manatees.
Squid Lips Overwater Grill has perfected the art of combining stunning location with food that lives up to the scenery, no small feat when your competition includes dolphins and spectacular sunsets. The name alone earns points for creativity, though the crispy calamari proves they back up the playful branding with serious cooking skills.
Their raw bar showcases oysters so fresh they taste like the ocean kissed them goodbye just minutes ago, served on ice with all the classic accompaniments. Grouper sandwiches achieve legendary status here, with generous portions of flaky white fish that overflow the bun in the most delightful way possible.
The tiki bar serves tropical drinks strong enough to make you forget about Monday morning while you watch boats cruise past your table. Live music on weekends transforms dinner into an event, with local musicians providing the soundtrack to your seafood adventure.
The combination of accessibility, atmosphere, and absolutely delicious food creates an experience that keeps customers coming back season after season.
Location: 1660 N Indian River Dr, Sebastian, FL 32958
5. Blackfins Riverfront Grill at Capt Hiram’s Resort
Nestled within the popular Capt Hiram’s Resort, Blackfins brings a touch of upscale elegance to Sebastian’s seafood scene without losing that essential Florida casualness.
This riverfront beauty serves dishes that look almost too pretty to eat—almost, because once you smell that perfectly seared tuna or butter-poached lobster, aesthetics take a backseat to appetite.
While Blackfins does not offer sushi or poke bowls, its menu focuses on classic coastal dishes like fresh catch entrées, shrimp, scallops, and well-prepared seafood staples that highlight natural flavors.
Their sushi menu surprises visitors who don’t expect to find quality raw fish preparations in a small coastal town, but the freshness speaks for itself. Tuna poke bowls arrive artfully arranged, combining creamy avocado, crisp vegetables, and melt-in-your-mouth fish that tastes like summer in a bowl.
Indoor and outdoor seating options mean you can enjoy waterfront views regardless of weather, though balmy Florida evenings practically demand patio dining.
Service elevates the experience with knowledgeable servers who can guide you through menu options and suggest perfect pairings. Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary or just treating yourself to something special, Blackfins delivers sophistication alongside seriously good seafood in a setting that feels both relaxed and refined.
Location: 1606 Indian River Dr, Sebastian, FL 32958
6. Sandbar Beach Club at Capt Hiram’s Resort
Sharing the same resort address as Blackfins but offering a completely different vibe, Sandbar Beach Club brings barefoot, beach-party energy to your seafood experience.
Sand between your toes and a cold drink in your hand set the stage for casual dining that feels more like a backyard barbecue than a restaurant visit.
The menu leans toward handheld favorites, fish tacos bursting with cabbage slaw and tangy sauce, shrimp po’boys that require multiple napkins, and conch fritters that disappear fast.
Live entertainment turns weekend afternoons into spontaneous dance parties where nobody judges your moves and everyone’s having too much fun to care.
The laid-back atmosphere attracts a younger crowd and families looking for entertainment beyond just eating, though the food alone justifies the visit. Prices stay budget-friendly, recognizing that beach vibes shouldn’t require beach-house budgets.
Sunset happy hours pack the place with locals and tourists alike, all chasing that perfect combination of discounted drinks, fresh seafood snacks, and golden-hour lighting that makes everything look Instagram-worthy. The casual dress code means swimsuit cover-ups and tank tops fit right in, making this the ultimate stop after a day on the water.
Location: 1606 Indian River Dr, Sebastian, FL 32958
7. Mulligan’s Beach House
Golf references meet beach culture at this charmingly quirky spot that proves you don’t need to take yourself too seriously to serve outstanding seafood.
Mulligan’s Beach House Bar & Grill embraces the laid-back philosophy that mistakes happen (hence the name) but great food and good times make everything better. The weathered wood decor and nautical touches create an atmosphere that feels lived-in and welcoming, like visiting a friend’s really cool beach cottage.
Their fish dip deserves legendary status, combining smoked fish with creamy, seasoned perfection that pairs beautifully with crackers and cold drinks. Grouper bites, Mulligan’s well-known version of grouper nuggets, arrive golden and crispy, offering bite-sized pieces of Florida heaven that work equally well as appetizers or main courses.
The bar pours generous drinks that don’t require a second mortgage, while the friendly bartenders remember regulars’ orders and make newcomers feel like old friends. Waterfront seating lets you watch the river traffic while working through a basket of fried shrimp that stays crispy down to the last piece.
Locals treat this place like their neighborhood hangout, creating a community atmosphere where conversations flow freely. The unpretentious vibe means you can show up straight from fishing and fit right in, still wearing your lucky fishing shirt and salt-crusted sandals.
Location: 806 Indian River Dr, Sebastian, FL 32958
8. Indian River Seafood Market
Sometimes the best way to enjoy fresh seafood involves buying it yourself and becoming the chef, which is where this market absolutely shines.
Indian River Seafood Market connects you directly with the ocean’s bounty, offering fish and shellfish so fresh you’ll want to check for gills still moving. Walking into this market feels like stepping onto a fishing boat, with the clean ocean smell and gleaming displays of the day’s catch arranged on ice.
Knowledgeable staff members answer questions about preparation methods, cooking times, and flavor profiles, turning nervous home cooks into confident seafood chefs. They’ll even clean and fillet your selections, removing any intimidation factor from preparing whole fish at home.
Beyond raw seafood, the market offers prepared items like crab cakes, soups, chowders, and smoked fish dip, making it easy to bring home high-quality seafood with minimal prep.
Prices reflect the quality and freshness, offering better value than grocery store seafood counters while supporting local businesses. Whether you’re planning an elaborate seafood feast or just want fresh fish for tonight’s dinner, this market delivers options that make home cooking feel special.
The friendly, helpful atmosphere encourages questions and experimentation, helping customers discover new favorite seafood varieties they might have overlooked at restaurants.
Location: 645 Sebastian Blvd, Unit 1, Sebastian, FL 32958
9. Sebastian’s Roadside Restaurant
Highway 1 travelers who zoom past this unassuming roadside spot have no idea what delicious opportunities they’re missing.
Sebastian’s Roadside Restaurant proves that great seafood doesn’t require waterfront views or fancy decor—just skilled cooks who know their way around fish. The classic diner atmosphere feels comfortingly familiar, with booth seating, friendly servers, and a menu that covers all the seafood greatest hits.
Their fried shrimp basket delivers exactly what you’re craving: plump shrimp in crispy coating, served with fries and coleslaw that completes the perfect comfort food experience. The fish and chips feature a mild white fish such as pollock rather than local catch, but still deliver that satisfying pub-style crunch with Florida flair.
Breakfast options may vary, and while classic diner fare is common, seafood omelets are not a regular staple here, but the hearty morning menu keeps both locals and travelers well fed. The coffee stays hot and flowing, with attentive servers keeping cups topped off between bites.
Prices stay remarkably reasonable, making this a spot where families can feed everyone without financial stress. Locals pop in for quick lunches, knowing they’ll get quality food served fast without sacrificing flavor or freshness.
The no-nonsense approach to service and cooking creates loyal customers who appreciate straightforward, delicious seafood without pretension. Sometimes the best meals happen at places that let the food do all the talking.
Location: 10795 US Highway 1, Sebastian, FL 32958
10. Sandy’s Grille
Tucked along Sebastian Boulevard, this neighborhood favorite treats every customer like family, serving portions that prove they want you well-fed and happy.
Sandy’s Grille operates on the philosophy that good food brings people together, creating a welcoming space where first-timers quickly become regulars. The menu balances seafood specialties with land-based options, recognizing that not everyone in your group might worship at the altar of fish and shellfish.
Their blackened grouper sandwich achieves that perfect balance of charred spices and tender, flaky fish that makes you understand why grouper earns such devoted fans. Crab cake platters remain popular menu items, though preparations may vary and some diners find them more traditional than “mostly crab,” offering a satisfying and generously portioned seafood option.
The casual atmosphere encourages lingering over meals, with servers who check in without hovering and genuinely seem to care about your dining experience. Daily specials keep the menu interesting for frequent visitors, showcasing seasonal catches and chef creativity.
Families appreciate the kid-friendly environment and menu options that satisfy picky eaters alongside adventurous diners. The combination of quality food, reasonable prices, and warm hospitality creates the kind of restaurant that becomes part of your regular rotation.
Local artwork decorates the walls, reinforcing the community connection that makes Sandy’s feel less like a restaurant and more like your favorite neighbor’s dining room. Comfortable, unpretentious, and consistently delicious—exactly what neighborhood dining should deliver.
Location: 171 Sebastian Blvd, Sebastian, FL 32958