We Ranked Florida’s Top Pizza Places And These 10 Made The Final Cut
A pizza covered in Nutella and banana sits on a Florida menu, and I need to talk about it. Somewhere else in the state, a slice shop keeps its ovens going until 3 AM, seven nights a week.
Another kitchen lists a Pistacchio pizza right beside the classic Margherita. One more spot serves taco pizza a short drive from the Gulf.
I love that kind of range, and I wanted to see more.
That mix is what made this ranking so fun to build. The list stretches from the Panhandle to the very bottom of the map, with thin crusts, brick ovens, and wood fires along the way.
I can’t stop thinking about how different each one feels.
A few picks sit close to sand and salt air, while busy city corners host the rest. So which one would you hit first, and how far would you drive for the right crust?
1. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Wynwood
Dessert pizza is not a joke here, and the menu proves it with a Nutella Pizza. There’s even a Nutella and banana calzone for anyone who wants a sweet finish folded up like a gift.
Before you get to the sweet stuff, though, the savory side deserves your full attention. The kitchen bakes traditional Italian thin-crust pizza with a crispy, balanced base.
Ingredients come from local sources or straight from Italy. That pairing gives you Florida freshness with old-country flavor in the same bite.
Prosciutto and arugula show up as toppings, which is a classic Italian combo. The salty ham and peppery greens play nicely on a crust that stays light.
Want to start small? The Burrata E Crudo and the Burrata with Italian balsamic glaze make strong opening moves for the table.
Salads like the Azzurra and a Caesar round things out if you want something green. You’ll also find calzones, including one called the Calzone Onju.
Plant-based eaters are covered with a full vegan menu and a full vegetarian menu. That makes group dinners a lot easier when friends eat differently.
The shop sits on North Miami Avenue in Wynwood, a Miami neighborhood famous for its outdoor murals. Pizza and street art in one outing feels like a smart day plan.
Hours run late on Friday and Saturday, until 11 PM. The restaurant operates on a walk-in-only basis, so reservations aren’t available.
Arriving a little earlier might help you beat the weekend rush.
Address: 2315 N Miami Ave, Miami, FL 33127
2. Piola Italian Restaurant Miami Beach
Collins Avenue is known for big hotels and ocean views, yet this stop keeps things down-to-earth. Think generous pies, a terrace, and a menu that doesn’t try to show off.
Pizza here comes with a crispy crust and fresh toppings. If you only order one thing, the signature pizza is the one to try.
Garlic knots make a great warm-up while you wait. They’re the kind of starter that disappears before anyone admits to grabbing the last one.
Pasta fans have plenty to explore too. The menu includes Lasagna Rina, Spaghetti Salento, Penne Rosate, and Penne Alfredo with chicken.
Save room for dessert, because the sweets list is strong. Tiramisu dusted with cocoa powder and profiteroles both make tempting finales.
Brunch is on the table here, which is a fun twist for a pizza place. Who says pizza can’t be a late-morning plan near the beach?
Bringing your pup? Dogs are allowed outside, so the terrace works for four-legged guests too.
Families will find high chairs and a kids’ menu ready to go. There’s also a full vegan menu, so dietary needs won’t derail the outing.
Doors open at noon and stay open until 11 PM daily. That long window makes it easy to fit a pie into a busy beach day.
Paid parking is the setup in this part of Miami Beach. Plan ahead and you’ll be eating faster.
Address: 4000 Collins Ave Apt B, Miami Beach, FL 33140
3. Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar
Night owls, this one’s for you, since the doors stay open until 3 AM seven days a week. That’s not a typo, and it’s a big deal in Tampa.
The pizzeria sits on East 7th Avenue in Ybor City, the historic district with brick streets and plenty of nightlife. It’s a handy stop when late-night hunger shows up.
NYC-style pies lead the menu. Expect a crispy crust, thin and sturdy enough to fold the way New Yorkers like it.
Topping choices cover the classics and then some. Pepperoni, buffalo chicken, a white pizza, and the Fresca pizza all make an appearance.
Garlic knots are a must for the table. Subs, appetizers, and stromboli give you options beyond the pie.
Fresh pasta is part of the deal too, including a vegan version. Chicken parmigiana is there for anyone craving a hearty Italian plate.
Got a sweet tooth? New York-style cannolis close out the meal with a classic crunch.
Counter service keeps things quick, which matters at 1 AM. Curbside pickup and delivery are available when you’d rather eat at home.
Sports fans will appreciate that it’s a good place to catch a game. Reservations aren’t taken, so just show up hungry.
Street parking is available nearby, with paid lots also in the area. Ybor gets busy, so give yourself a few extra minutes.
Address: 1724 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
4. V Pizza & Tap Room – Lake Buena Vista
Wood-fired chicken wings at a pizza place? Yes, and they share the spotlight with brick-oven pies that lean authentic Italian.
Palm Parkway puts this spot close to the theme park zone of Orlando. It’s a smart refuel stop after a long day of rides and lines.
The brick oven handles the pizza, giving crusts that classic char. Menu highlights include The V Pizza and the Quattro Formaggi, both vegetarian.
Want something smoky? The Smokey BBQ brings a different flavor lane for anyone tired of plain red sauce.
Now, about those wings. The Calabrian Wings come out of the wood fire, and that pepper-forward name tells you there’s some kick.
Stromboli fans can grab the Con Carne Stromboli, packed for meat lovers. A Caprese salad or side Caesar keeps things lighter.
Tiramisu makes a sweet ending that won’t weigh you down for the drive back to the hotel. It’s a classic for good reason.
Families get high chairs and a kids’ menu, which helps after a tiring park day. Dogs are welcome on the outdoor seating, too.
A full vegan menu is available, so plant-based travelers don’t get left out. Reservations are accepted if your group is large.
Free parking is usually easy to find here, a rare treat in this busy part of Florida. Hours stretch to 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Address: 8586 Palm Pkwy, Orlando, FL 32836
5. Moon River Pizza
A pizza named the T-Rex should tell you this place has a sense of humor. It’s a meat lover’s special, and the name fits the appetite it creates.
The room is funky and colorful, with artwork that gives the space real personality. Music plays in the background, adding to the laid-back mood.
Dough is handmade daily and stone-baked. You can order big slices or whole pies, depending on how hungry your crew is.
The Special is the loaded choice, piled with pepperoni, Italian sausage, sliced meatballs, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and extra cheese. That’s a lot of pizza in one bite.
Prefer no red sauce? The White pizza mixes mozzarella, feta, and parmesan with olive oil, oregano, black pepper, and fresh garlic.
The Maui brings ham, pineapple, and cheddar to the party. You can add jalapeños or banana peppers if you want some heat.
Calzones, salads, cheese bread, and cannolis fill out the rest of the menu. A full vegan menu is available too.
Edgewood Avenue sits in a busy Jacksonville neighborhood, and parking can be tricky. Give yourself a little extra time to find a space.
Reservations aren’t taken, and the doors stay closed on Sundays. Plan your craving for Monday through Saturday, from 11 AM to 10 PM.
Address: 1176 Edgewood Ave S, Jacksonville, FL 32205
6. Original Flavor 1889
That 1889 in the name nods to the year often linked with the birth of the Margherita pizza in Naples. Fitting, since Neapolitan pizza is the star here.
Downtown St. Petersburg is the setting, right on Central Avenue. The street is packed with shops and restaurants, so it’s an easy add to a stroll.
Neapolitan pies come with a crisp crust and full flavor. The Margherita with fresh basil is the classic order for first-timers.
Curious about something unusual? The Pistacchio pizza is a top seller and a fun break from the usual toppings.
Calzones are on the menu too, including a piccante version with some spice. Homemade pasta gives non-pizza eaters a solid reason to tag along.
Starters include meatballs, fried calamari, and a burrata salad. Ordering a few to share is a great way to sample the kitchen.
Dessert brings cannoli and tiramisu, both Italian favorites. Pick one, or split both if you’re feeling bold.
Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are allowed outside. That makes it a nice pick for a sunny Florida evening downtown.
Hours shift during the week, so check before you go. Mondays and Tuesdays start at 4 PM, while the rest of the week opens at 11 AM.
Street parking is paid and can be tough to grab. Reservations are accepted, which helps on busy weekend nights.
Address: 409 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33701
7. Momo’s Pizza – Pensacola Street
Slices here are huge, the kind that hang off the plate and make you rethink your folding strategy. Thin crust keeps them manageable, mostly.
Pensacola Street sits near Florida State University in Tallahassee. That makes it a natural stop for students, visiting families, and anyone in town for a game.
You can order by the slice or the whole pie. Pepperoni and sausage slices are big hits for good reason.
One menu highlight stands out right away: a slice with Bradley’s Sausage and honey. Sweet and savory together is a combo worth trying at least once.
The Meaty Momo and the Meat Lovers pizza are built for serious carnivores. Bring a friend, or bring a box for later.
Calzones get attention too, like the pesto chicken calzone. Cheese sticks round out the starters for snackers.
Plant-based eaters have options beyond a basic side salad. Vegan-friendly ingredients and customizable pizzas give visitors some flexibility, while vegetarian diners can explore additional combinations.
Kids are welcome, with high chairs and a kids’ menu ready. Outdoor seating means dogs can join the fun on the patio.
Sports fans will like that it’s a good place to catch a game. In a college town, that’s practically a requirement.
Parking is usually plentiful, which is a nice surprise near campus. Reservations are accepted, and curbside pickup is offered too.
Address: 1641 W Pensacola St, Tallahassee, FL 32304
8. Lillian’s Pizza
Taco pizza near the beach sounds like a summer vacation idea, and it’s a real menu item here. Sand in your shoes is optional.
Perdido Key Drive puts this spot close to the Gulf, west of Pensacola. It’s a down-to-earth stop with a patio, perfect after a day in the sun.
The thin crust gets the most attention. It’s light and crisp, topped with creamy mozzarella and a sauce that makes people come back.
Pan pizzas are on the menu for anyone who wants a thicker bite. Stuffed pizza goes even further for the truly hungry.
Beyond the taco pie, you’ll find a white pizza and an Italian meatball option. Stromboli and sandwiches give you more ways to eat.
A salad bar is part of the setup, which is handy after a heavy beach lunch. Garlic bread knots and cheesy garlic bread make great sides.
Families will feel right at home here. High chairs, a kids’ menu, and a setup good for kids’ birthday parties make planning easy.
Dogs are allowed outside, so your pup can join the patio crowd. Free parking is usually easy to find, too.
Doors open at 11 AM and close at 9 PM, seven days a week. Reservations aren’t taken, so just roll in.
Hungry crew after the beach? This corner of Florida has a slice waiting.
Address: 14514 Perdido Key Dr, Pensacola, FL 32507
9. Carmelo’s Pizzeria
Big dollops of ricotta crown the Ortolana pie, alongside mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, and sliced Italian sausage. It’s a garden and a deli on one crust.
King Street runs through St. Augustine, the oldest city in the country. After wandering those historic streets, a hearty slice sounds pretty perfect.
NY-style pizza is the focus here, with a crust heated in a brick oven. The sauce leans rich and a little sweet.
Toppings like fresh peppers, mushrooms, onions, and meatballs are popular choices. Pepperoni fans won’t be disappointed either.
Carmelo’s Supreme Pizza is a signature order. The stuffed Carmelo’s slice is another one to keep on your radar.
Starters include garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and calamari. Stromboli and a Greek salad round out the lineup.
Little ones get their own menu, including spaghetti with marinara. High chairs are available for the smallest guests.
The space feels quaint, with decor that suits the old city around it. Outdoor seating is also offered, and dogs are allowed outside.
Hours run until 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. That’s helpful when sightseeing runs long and dinner gets late.
Parking downtown can be tricky to find. Reservations aren’t taken, so plan a short walk and arrive hungry.
Address: 146 W King St, St. Augustine, FL 32084
10. Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria
The name says it all, since wood fire powers the pizza oven here. At the far end of Florida, that smoky crust is worth the long drive south.
Duval Street is Key West’s busiest strip, full of music and people. This trattoria offers a breather with a shaded garden patio.
Pizza comes out of the wood oven fresh and light. The dough is thick and fluffy, with that classic char along the edges.
The 4 Stagioni splits toppings into four sections, like a pizza sampler. The Tartufata brings truffle flavor for something richer.
Want the classic? A small Margherita Special works well as a starter or a solo dinner.
The kitchen goes beyond pizza with Italian trattoria plates. Lasagna, bucatini cacio e pepe, and pollo al funghi are all on the menu.
Seafood lovers can order cozze e vongole, a mussels and clams dish. Burratina with prosciutto di Parma and arugula makes a lovely opener.
The setting leans romantic, especially out on the patio. It’s a nice pick for a date night after sunset.
Hours change with the seasons here. From November through April, Onlywood welcomes guests from noon to 10 PM, making lunch on the garden patio a tempting option.
From May through October, doors open at 5:30 PM and close at 10 PM, so dinner becomes the main event.
Reservations are accepted, and they’re smart on weekends. Paid parking is the norm here, so walking from nearby may be easier.
Address: 613-1/2 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040