We Ranked The 12 Best Amish Markets In Ohio And Here Are The Results
I usually know an Amish market trip has gone off script when the cooler is full before lunch.
A few cheese samples turn into a bakery box, then somehow there are three jars of jam wedged beside everything else.
That is part of the fun of shopping around Ohio’s Amish Country. Some markets are big enough to wander for an hour, while others feel more like the kind of place locals stop by for groceries every week.
After comparing the stops that kept giving me a reason to linger, I narrowed the list to 12. I ranked them by selection, food, and how much the visit itself feels worth the drive.
Bring a cooler and leave more trunk space than you think you need. The countdown starts with a market that makes overbuying dangerously easy.
1. Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek
Cheese lovers, meet your headquarters. The sampling trays here make it very hard to leave with an empty bag.
Walnut Creek Cheese & Market sits at 2641 OH-39 in Walnut Creek, Ohio, in the heart of Amish Country. The building is huge, so grab a cart before you start browsing.
The cheese selection is the star, and local varieties fill the cases from end to end. You will also find fresh meats, homemade baked goods, bulk foods, and seasonal produce that changes as the year moves along.
The kitchenware department is a surprise bonus. Gadgets, pans, and baking tools line the shelves, so a quick stop can turn into a full kitchen makeover.
When hunger hits, the on-site café is ready with a warm meal. That makes it easy to shop for an hour, sit down for lunch, and then shop some more.
My tip is to start with the samples, then circle back for your favorites. Your cooler will thank you, and so will your sandwich plans for the week.
Few places in Ohio pack this much country goodness under one roof, which explains the top spot on my list.
2. Troyer Market, Millersburg
Deli meat fans, your moment has arrived. The counter at Troyer Market is stacked with premium cuts that make lunch plans easy.
You will find it at 5201 Co Rd 77 in Millersburg, Ohio, close to Berlin. It sits right in the rolling hills of Holmes County.
Beyond the deli, the shelves hold locally produced cheeses, homemade sweets, and a wide range of Amish pantry staples. The grocery selection is bigger than many people expect from a country stop.
Fresh produce adds color near the front, and the whole place feels friendly and unhurried. Staff members are happy to point you toward a good snack or a trusty pantry item.
I like to build a picnic here. A few slices of meat, a wedge of cheese, a sweet treat, and some crackers make a fine lunch by the roadside.
Troyer Market also works well as a first stop on a Holmes County day trip. Stock up on supplies, then wander the nearby shops with a happy bag swinging from your arm.
It earns a high ranking for freshness, variety, and a welcome that feels genuine.
3. Ashery Country Store, Fredericksburg
Bakers, grab a big basket. The bulk aisles at Ashery Country Store are built for people who measure flour by the bag.
The store is found at 8922 OH-241 in Fredericksburg, Ohio, near Mount Hope. The drive alone is lovely, with farms and fields on both sides of the road.
Inside, baking ingredients fill row after row, along with fresh deli products and locally grown produce. Traditional Amish Country favorites sit alongside everyday groceries, so you can fill a whole pantry in one trip.
Prices are reasonable, which is a big reason shoppers keep returning. Buying in bulk here can stretch a grocery budget without sacrificing quality.
Bring a list, but leave room for surprises. A jar of something pickled or a bag of unusual candy often jumps into the cart without much persuasion.
The atmosphere feels like real rural Ohio shopping, with no fuss and plenty of friendly faces. It is the kind of place where regulars chat in the aisles about recipes.
Ashery Country Store lands high on my list because it delivers value, variety, and a true country feel.
4. Nauvoo Family Market, Middlefield
Doughnuts first, questions later. The bakery case at Nauvoo Family Market has a way of settling every debate about breakfast.
This family-run stop is at 15979 Nauvoo Rd in Middlefield, Ohio, in the northeastern part of the state. It brings an Amish bakery, bulk food department, deli, and hardware store together under one roof.
Freshly prepared doughnuts and homemade fry pies draw the biggest crowds. Grab a box early, because the best flavors tend to disappear before lunchtime.
The bulk section offers traditional grocery staples, and the deli adds locally inspired foods for sandwiches and snacks. A hardware store in the same building is a handy extra.
That mix makes the market useful for more than snacks. You can pick up a loaf of bread, a bag of noodles, and a box of screws in a single visit.
I love how practical and welcoming it feels. Northeastern Ohio’s Amish Country does not get as much attention as Holmes County, so the crowds stay friendlier.
Nauvoo Family Market earns its spot with sweet treats, handy shopping, and a hometown spirit.
5. The Amish Market, Boardman
Not everyone has time for a long country drive. Luckily, the Amish shopping experience comes to the city here.
The Amish Market sits at 6121 South Ave in Boardman, Ohio. It is a spacious indoor farmers market where independent vendors share one big roof.
Walk the aisles and you will spot fresh produce, baked goods, deli meats, handmade furniture, and traditional country foods. Each vendor brings a different specialty, so no two stalls feel alike.
The variety is the main charm. You can taste a pastry at one booth, order sliced meat at another, and admire a wooden table a few steps later.
Because the market is indoors, the weather never ruins your plans. Rain or snow, the shelves stay full and the aisles stay cozy.
I recommend a slow lap before buying anything. That way you can compare vendors, sample a bit, and decide where your money tastes best.
For visitors who want Amish-style shopping without traveling deep into rural Ohio, this market is a convenient and tasty answer.
6. Planktown Country Market, Shiloh
Out among the farm fields of north-central Ohio, a quiet market waits for hungry travelers. Planktown Country Market does not need flashy signs to get attention.
The address is 1921 Free Rd in Shiloh, Ohio. Fields stretch in every direction, which sets a relaxed mood before you even park.
Inside, bulk foods fill the shelves alongside fresh deli meats, cheeses, and baking supplies. Country grocery products round out the selection, so you can restock the pantry in one pass.
The pace here is easygoing. Nobody rushes you, and the shelves invite slow reading of labels and careful choosing.
I like to pick up a few baking staples and a pound of cheese. Add a bit of sliced meat, and a simple lunch is ready for the road.
Shoppers who love traditional Amish Country staples will feel right at home. It is a good choice if you want less bustle and more genuine rural charm.
The calm atmosphere and solid selection make Planktown a rewarding stop in this part of Ohio.
7. Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery, Millersburg
Pumpkins stacked like orange building blocks greet you in the fall. Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery turns autumn into a full event.
You will find it at 5452 OH-557 in Millersburg, Ohio, in the Holmes County countryside. The setting feels like a postcard, with barns and hills nearby.
The traditional Amish bakery is the first stop for many visitors. Homemade baked goods and locally inspired treats fill the cases, and the smell alone can steer your feet.
The farm store adds seasonal produce, pumpkins, and more. Extra farm attractions make it easy to turn a quick shopping trip into a family outing.
Kids enjoy the open space, and adults enjoy the pastries. Everybody leaves with something in hand, which makes planning simple.
Fall is the best time to visit, when the colors and the harvest peak together. Bring a camera, because the display photos practically take themselves.
Hershberger’s wins a spot on my list as an especially joyful place to be during Ohio’s autumn season.
8. Yoder’s Bakery & Furniture, Seaman
Southern Ohio has its own Amish treasure, and the sandwiches alone are worth the drive. Yoder’s Bakery & Furniture, formerly known as Keim Family Market, proves it.
The market is located at 2621 Burnt Cabin Rd in Seaman, Ohio. It serves visitors exploring the Amish communities of Adams County.
Fresh bakery products are on display near the entrance, and deli sandwiches are ready for a quick lunch. Bulk foods and preserves fill the shelves in tidy, colorful rows.
Handcrafted furniture adds another reason to wander. Even if you only came for snacks, a sturdy wooden chair might tempt you.
The shopping areas are spacious, so there is room to browse without bumping carts. That makes it comfortable for families and small groups.
I suggest grabbing a sandwich, picking out a jar of preserves, and eating on the road while you explore. The hills of Adams County make a lovely backdrop for lunch.
Yoder’s earns its ranking by offering food, furniture, and room to roam in one countryside stop.
9. Swiss Village Bulk Foods, Sugarcreek
Since 1980, shoppers in Sugarcreek have counted on one place for pantry restocking. Swiss Village Bulk Foods has earned that loyalty the slow way.
Find it at 309 S Broadway St in Sugarcreek, Ohio. The shop offers thousands of products, so a quick visit is nearly impossible.
Baking supplies, spices, specialty groceries, health foods, and household essentials all share the shelves. If a recipe calls for it, there is a good chance it is here.
The deli counter is a big draw. Meats and cheeses are sliced fresh, and the selection is wide enough to please picky eaters.
I like to bring a list and then ignore half of it. The spice aisle is a rabbit hole of flavors, and the health food section hides some great finds.
The store feels organized and welcoming, even when it is busy. Staff members know their products and happily answer questions.
For dependable traditional Amish Country shopping, Swiss Village Bulk Foods is a trusty choice in Ohio.
10. Walnut Creek Marketplace, Sugarcreek
Treasure hunters, loosen those walking shoes. The aisles here change so often that every visit feels like a first.
Walnut Creek Marketplace, formerly the Walnut Creek Amish Flea Market, sits at 1900 OH-39 in Sugarcreek, Ohio. It is a large indoor space filled with dozens of independent vendors.
Handmade crafts, Amish furniture, and quilts catch the eye first. Antiques, collectibles, and specialty foods tuck into the corners and reward patient browsing.
The constantly changing selection is the real magic. A booth that was empty last month might now be packed with old tools or hand-stitched blankets.
I like to set a small budget and a time limit. Without them, a day can slip away between the vintage signs and the jars of homemade relish.
Chatting with vendors adds to the fun, since many love to share the story behind their goods. You might learn how a quilt pattern got its name.
That bustling variety makes this one of the most entertaining shopping destinations in Ohio’s Amish Country.
11. Kidron Town & Country Store, Kidron
Founded in 1929, this store has watched nearly a century of Kidron mornings roll by. Kidron Town & Country Store still feels proudly small-town.
The address is 4959 Kidron Rd in Kidron, Ohio. It serves the community and the nearby Amish farms.
The traditional meat counter is a highlight, with fresh cuts that locals trust. Locally produced cheeses, bulk foods, and seasonal produce fill out the rest of the store.
Everyday grocery essentials are here too, so it works for a quick errand as well as a special trip. That blend of practical and charming sets it apart.
Close ties to the surrounding Amish farming community show in the quality of the goods. Fresh items often come from nearby hands.
I enjoy the simple pace of the place. Folks greet each other by name, and visitors get a friendly nod too.
For an authentic small-town shopping experience in Ohio, Kidron Town & Country Store is a sweet and steady stop.
12. Miller’s Bulk Foods, West Union
Spice lovers, take note. The shelves at Miller’s Bulk Foods are ready to upgrade your cooking.
The store is at 930 Wheat Ridge Rd in West Union, Ohio, in southern Ohio’s Amish Country. The quiet roads leading there set a calm mood.
Baking ingredients, spices, deli meats, and cheeses fill the aisles. Preserves and specialty grocery products add color and flavor to the mix.
The selection is extensive, so plan to wander. Each aisle seems to hold a new jar, bag, or snack worth tossing into the cart.
Nearby, Amish-made furniture and bakery offerings make the surrounding area fun to explore. You can pair grocery shopping with a peek at sturdy tables and fresh pastries.
I suggest turning the visit into a countryside shopping trip. Pick up supplies, grab a baked treat, and let the scenery do the rest.
Miller’s Bulk Foods rounds out my list with a flavorful finish in the southern corner of Ohio.