We Ranked The Best Pizza Places In Florida And Here Is Who Made The Cut

Finding great pizza in Florida is easy.

Agreeing on which place does it best is where the trouble starts.

Across the Sunshine State, neighborhood pizzerias are stretching dough, firing up ovens, and serving everything from thin, foldable New York-style slices to blistered pies with crispy edges and bubbling cheese.

Naturally, we had to rank them.

Our search took us from the Panhandle to South Florida, with plenty of cheesy detours in between. Some of these places have been feeding loyal regulars for years.

Others are newer spots quickly building serious followings. What they have in common is the kind of pizza that makes eating one more slice seem like an excellent idea.

We looked for great crust, flavorful sauce, quality toppings, and, most importantly, pizza worth going out of your way to eat.

There were plenty of contenders, but only ten made the final list.

Grab the red pepper flakes and prepare to disagree with at least one ranking.

Here are ten of the best pizza places in Florida and who made the cut.

1. Tony D’s New York Pizza & Restaurant, Jacksonville

Folding a slice in half is practically a sport in New York, and Tony D’s has brought that game straight to Jacksonville. You can find this local favorite at 8358 Point Meadows Dr #10, Jacksonville, FL 32256.

Regulars swear the first bite feels like a quick trip to Brooklyn without the plane ticket.

The crust here is thin, crisp on the bottom, and soft enough to fold without cracking. Sauce is bright and slightly sweet, while the cheese melts into that perfect golden blanket everyone dreams about.

Grab a plain cheese slice first, because it shows off the basics better than anything else.

Hungry crews will love the big menu, which includes pasta, subs, wings, and calzones stuffed to the brim. Families often order a large pie and a side of garlic knots, and nobody ever leaves grumpy.

Staff members are friendly and quick, which makes weeknight dinners feel easy.

Here is a handy tip: call ahead on Friday nights, since this spot gets busy fast. Want something bolder?

Try a specialty pie loaded with meats or veggies. Either way, Tony D’s proves you do not need a subway map to enjoy a true slice of the Big Apple.

2. Decent Pizza, Tallahassee

Calling yourself decent when you are actually amazing takes serious humility. Decent Pizza, located at 1026 N Monroe St, Tallahassee, FL 32303, is the kind of place that undersells itself and then knocks your socks off.

Think of it as the shy kid in class who turns out to be a genius.

Creative toppings are the star of the show here. You will see combos that sound wild at first, like sweet and spicy mixes or fresh herbs piled high, yet every pie tastes balanced and thoughtful.

The crust has a light, airy chew with a pleasant crunch around the edges.

College students, local families, and state workers all pack into this laid-back hangout. The vibe is relaxed and artsy, with a patio that is perfect for warm Florida evenings.

It feels like a neighborhood living room where pizza happens to be the guest of honor.

Planning a visit? Bring a friend and split two different pies so you can sample more flavors.

Salads here are fresh and crunchy too, making a nice partner for your slices. After one meal, you will probably agree that decent is the understatement of the year, and you will want to come back soon.

3. New York’s Famous Pizza And Pasta, Panama City

Beach days burn a lot of energy, and few things refuel a sandy family faster than a hot pie. New York’s Famous Pizza and Pasta sits at 1000 E 23rd St, Panama City, FL 32405, ready to rescue hungry swimmers and sunbathers.

The name is bold, and happily, the food lives up to the bragging.

Big, hand-tossed pizzas come out with generous toppings and a sturdy crust that holds everything in place. Pepperoni curls into crispy little cups, which fans call the best part.

Pasta dishes are just as popular, with rich sauces and portions large enough to share.

Fun fact: pizza became popular across America after soldiers returned from Italy in the 1940s craving it. This shop keeps that tradition alive with recipes that feel classic and comforting.

Kids will love the simple cheese slices, while adults may lean toward loaded specialty pies.

Service is quick and welcoming, so it works well for a lunch break or a lazy dinner. Ask about lunch specials, which give you plenty of food for a friendly price.

Whether you are a local or just visiting the Gulf Coast, this spot serves smiles alongside every steaming plate.

4. Lee’s Grocery, Tampa

Who knew a grocery store name could hide one of Tampa’s tastiest secrets? Lee’s Grocery, at 2210 N Central Ave, Tampa, FL 33602, lives in a charming old corner building with plenty of history.

Today, the shelves of canned goods have been swapped for something far more exciting: pizza.

Crusts here have beautiful bubbly edges with little toasted spots, a sign of a very hot oven at work. Each pie tastes fresh, with bright tomato sauce and quality cheese that melts just right.

Toppings are carefully chosen, so every bite feels balanced instead of overloaded.

Located in the Tampa Heights area, Lee’s is a great stop if you are exploring the Riverwalk or nearby parks. The space feels cozy and modern, mixing old charm with a stylish look.

Outdoor seating lets you enjoy the breeze while you munch.

Our advice is simple: order a classic margherita first to taste the craft behind the dough. Then branch out to a creative special if you still have room.

Lee’s Grocery shows that the best things sometimes come in surprising packages, and this one comes with a perfectly charred crust.

5. Antonella’s Pizzeria Fairbanks, Winter Park

Sometimes a pizza tastes like a warm hug from a favorite aunt. Antonella’s Pizzeria Fairbanks, found at 360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789, serves exactly that kind of comfort.

The family-style spirit here makes first-time visitors feel like longtime regulars.

Neighborhood folks rave about the garlic knots, which are soft, buttery, and dangerously easy to keep eating. Pizzas come with a golden crust and a sauce that tastes slow-cooked and full of flavor.

Square grandma-style slices are worth trying if you like a thicker, crispier bite.

Winter Park is known for its pretty streets and lakes, and Antonella’s fits right into that friendly feeling. It sits close to Rollins College, so you will spot students grabbing slices between classes.

Families, couples, and solo diners all find a comfy place at the table.

Want a winning plan? Start with garlic knots, share a big pie, and save room for a sweet treat like cannoli.

The staff is cheerful and happy to suggest favorites if you cannot decide. Leaving Antonella’s without a full belly and a big smile is nearly impossible, and honestly, that is the whole point.

6. Nico’s Pizza, West Palm Beach

Clematis Street buzzes with shops, music, and fountains, and right in the middle of the fun is Nico’s Pizza. You can grab a slice at 301 Clematis St, West Palm Beach, FL 33401.

It is the ultimate pit stop for anyone wandering downtown with a rumbling tummy.

Slices here are big, floppy in the best way, and served hot enough to make you blow on the first bite. The cheese stretches like taffy, and the crust has a satisfying crunch underneath.

Pepperoni lovers, prepare to be very happy.

Ready for a fun bit of trivia? The fountain near the waterfront nearby is a favorite splash spot for kids, so a slice plus a splash makes a perfect afternoon.

Nico’s has a quick-service style that makes it easy to eat on the go or grab a seat and people-watch.

Late-night cravings are no problem either, since this shop is a go-to for evening crowds. Pick up a whole pie for a picnic by the water if the weather is nice.

Nico’s proves that great pizza and a great location make a pretty unbeatable team, like peanut butter and jelly, but cheesier.

7. Andiamo! Brick Oven Pizza, Miami

Andiamo means let’s go in Italian, and trust us, you will want to go immediately. Andiamo!

Brick Oven Pizza sits at 5600 Biscayne Blvd, Miami, FL 33137, in the lively MiMo district. The building itself is a former tire shop, which gives it a quirky, retro charm you will not forget.

Everything comes out of a roaring brick oven, so crusts are blistered, smoky, and perfectly chewy. Toppings range from classic margherita to creative pies with Miami flair.

Each pizza is sized well for sharing, but nobody will judge you for keeping one all to yourself.

Seating is mostly outdoors, which makes it a breezy spot to enjoy Miami weather. Colorful murals and a relaxed crowd give the place a fun, artsy energy.

It is the kind of hangout where friends linger long after the last slice disappears.

Visiting with a group? Order a few different pies and pass them around like a tasting party.

Weekends can get busy, so arriving a little early helps you snag a good table. Andiamo! turns a simple dinner into a mini vacation, and the only souvenir you need is a happy, full stomach.

8. Uncle Rico’s Pizza, Fort Myers

Every family has that one fun uncle, and in Fort Myers, his name is Rico. Uncle Rico’s Pizza welcomes hungry guests at 2960 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901.

The name alone makes people smile before they even taste a crumb.

Generous toppings are the calling card here, piled on with a happy hand. Meat lovers will find plenty to cheer about, while veggie fans get colorful, fresh options too.

The crust is sturdy enough to carry the load without turning soggy, which is a true pizza superpower.

Locals love the easygoing atmosphere and the friendly faces behind the counter. It is a great place for game nights, birthday treats, or a simple dinner when nobody wants to cook.

Wings and sides round out the menu if your group wants a little bit of everything.

Quick tip from our taste testers: try a specialty pie with a drizzle of ranch or hot honey if offered. Takeout travels well, so it is perfect for a beach evening on Fort Myers Beach nearby.

Uncle Rico’s feels like a family reunion where the best guest at the table is always a hot, cheesy pizza.

9. Leonardo’s Pizza Of Millhopper, Gainesville

Gainesville runs on school spirit, sunshine, and a whole lot of pizza. Leonardo’s Pizza of Millhopper, at 4131 NW 16th Blvd, Gainesville, FL 32605, has been feeding students and families for years.

Ask a local where to eat, and this name pops up quicker than a Gator chomp.

Pies here have a soft, bready crust with a golden edge that is great for dipping. Toppings are fresh, and the sauce has a cozy homemade taste.

Many fans also rave about the salads, which are crisp and generous enough to pair perfectly with a slice.

Did you know? Gainesville is home to the University of Florida, one of the largest universities in the country, so pizza demand here is huge.

Leonardo’s keeps up with that demand while still making each pie feel special. It is a favorite for study breaks, team dinners, and post-game celebrations.

Booths are comfy, and the atmosphere is calm enough for real conversation. Try a slice of the deep dish style if you want something extra hearty.

Leonardo’s is proof that some places become a tradition, passed down from class to class like a tasty secret everyone wants to share.

10. Georgio’s Pizza, Pensacola

Last on our list but definitely not least, Georgio’s Pizza brings the heat to the western tip of Florida. Swing by 3000 E Cervantes St, Pensacola, FL 32503, and you will see why locals keep coming back.

Some places save the best for last, and our ranking did the same.

Hand-tossed crusts come out golden and puffy, with just enough crunch to make every bite satisfying. The cheese is melty and plentiful, and the sauce strikes a sweet and tangy balance.

Specialty pies offer loads of combos, so picky eaters and adventurous eaters can both find a winner.

Pensacola is one of the oldest settlements in the United States, and Georgio’s feels like a cozy part of that hometown story. Neighbors meet here, kids celebrate wins, and families share big pies after long days.

The staff treats everyone with warm, Southern friendliness.

Heading to Pensacola Beach for the day? Pick up a pizza on the way home and end the day on a delicious note.

Calzones and subs are also worth a try if you want a change. Georgio’s wraps up our tour with a cheesy bow, and your taste buds will thank you.