We Ranked The 10 Greatest Pizza Places In Pennsylvania And Here Is Who Made The Cut
A tiny pizza shop that once made only about 160 pies a week got named the best pizza in America by Bon Appetit in 2015.
That number still makes me laugh. Plenty of shops crank out that many before dinner.
The lines that followed became legend, and the shop eventually moved into a bigger home with 80 seats.
I love that kind of story. It proves great pizza can start small and still shake up the whole country.
Pennsylvania is full of moments like that. One town builds its pies in rectangular trays and serves them in cuts.
Another spot drizzles hot honey over its own sauce for a sweet kick. So I started digging into the pies worth a long drive across the state.
The final list covers big cities, small towns, and a few surprises. Which slice are you grabbing first?
1. Pizzeria Beddia
Few pizzerias can say a national magazine crowned them the best in America.
Bon Appétit gave that title to this Fishtown spot in 2015, back when it was a tiny takeout shop.
Those early days meant about 160 pies a week and lines that became famous. In March 2019, the shop reopened at its current address with approximately 90 seats and a full staff.
The menu stays short, and that’s the point. You’ll find a focused selection of pies, including the spicy Angry Pizza, along with small plates like Red Cat Cheese.
Craving something lighter on the side? The Chicory Caesar Salad and Judion Beans give your table a break, and Cantabrian Anchovies wait for the bold crowd.
The pies come out of hot deck ovens with a thin, crisp crust and fresh tomato sauce. A double slice of Tomato Pie works well if you want a taste of something classic.
Save room for the soft-serve ice cream, which has its own following. There’s also a Hoagie Room, a private dining space that groups can book.
Planning matters here, since there’s usually a wait. Reservations are accepted and recommended for dinner, and parking nearby can be tricky.
Weekday dinners start at 5 PM, while Friday through Sunday open at noon. Tuesday nights tend to be the quietest.
Address: 1313 N Lee St, Philadelphia, PA 19122
2. Pizza Lupo
Grandma would approve of this place, since the Grandma Pie sits near the top of the menu.
You’ll find it at a Lawrenceville pizza shop on Butler Street. Pizza Lupo calls itself an artisanal pizza restaurant, with specialty pies and sandwiches leading the way.
The crust lands in a happy middle, crispy on the outside with a satisfying chew.
Sauce gets serious attention here too. You can even order a side of pizza sauce, which tells you how proud the kitchen is of it.
Want something with more attitude? The Large Buffalo Chicken pie brings the heat for anyone who likes wings and pizza in one bite.
Service runs through the counter, so don’t expect a server to take your order. It’s built for quick lunches, easy dinners, and families who want a casual night out.
Takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery are all options. That’s handy, since there’s no restroom on site.
Timing helps in this part of Pittsburgh. Friday and Saturday evenings get busy, while weekday afternoons tend to be calmer.
The shop is closed Sundays and Mondays and opens at 3 PM Tuesday through Thursday. Friday and Saturday service starts at noon, and reservations aren’t taken, so just stop by.
Address: 5123 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA 15201
3. Revello’s Pizza Cafe
Old Forge calls itself the Pizza Capital of the World, and this family-owned cafe has been backing up that claim since 1967. That’s a lot of trays.
Pizza here comes Old Forge style, which means rectangular trays served in cuts instead of round slices. The crust is light and fluffy with a crisp edge.
Sharing is the whole idea. Order a tray for the table and let everyone grab their own cut.
The Red Pizza is a solid first pick if you’re new to the style. From-scratch pastas and sandwiches round out the menu for anyone who wants a detour.
Families fit right in, with high chairs and a kids’ menu on hand. The setting feels historic, which suits a place with nearly six decades behind it.
Got a game to catch? The cafe is known as a good spot for watching sports, and live music shows up too.
Hours stretch later than many pizzerias in Pennsylvania. It’s open until 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays, and Monday service starts at 4:30 PM.
Reservations are accepted, and parking is usually easy. Friday evening is the busiest time, so plan around it.
Address: 502 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518
4. Pasquale’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Handmade crust and house tomato sauce are part of the appeal at this Lancaster pizzeria.
The menu offers everything from classic cheese pizza to specialty pies loaded with toppings.
The variety is a fun surprise, but the basics are strong too. Pies are made to order with a crisp crust and fresh toppings.
The menu goes well beyond pizza. Chicken Parm, Stuffed Shells, Lobster Ravioli, and Chicken Formaggi all share space with sandwiches and burgers.
Starting light? Bruschetta and Ranch Fries make easy openers for the table.
Dessert deserves a plan of its own. The Italian Cannoli is a popular way to finish, and the restaurant is known for great desserts.
The interior has a look you won’t confuse with a chain, and the mood stays casual and quiet. You can sit down for table service, order at the counter, or grab a seat outside.
Bringing kids along is easy, with high chairs, changing tables, and a kids’ menu. Vegetarian and vegan diners can also find suitable options, which is a nice touch.
Pasquale’s sits on Old Philadelphia Pike with a free parking lot that usually has space. It’s closed Sundays and Mondays, and Friday evenings fill up fastest.
Address: 1657 Old Philadelphia Pike, Lancaster, PA 17602
5. Colony Pizza
Not every great pie needs a gimmick.
In Erie, this spot wins people over with thin, crispy pizza that does its job without showing off.
The sauce gets attention for its balance. It has a little spice that wakes things up without taking over.
Little pepperoni is a favorite topping here, scattered across that thin crust. Quality toppings and fresh dough keep things simple and satisfying.
Feeling extra hungry? The Meatza loads up on meat, while the Sausage and Basil Margherita Pizza mixes classic and hearty.
Calzone fans can go big with the Large Calzone. The Meatball Parm makes a strong case for sandwich lovers too.
Wings also earn a spot on the order, and the salads are hearty. Then comes dessert, where Cinna-Knots bring a sweet, cinnamon finish.
Colony also runs a catering side, which helps if you’re feeding a crowd. Families are welcome, and there’s outdoor seating when Lake Erie weather cooperates.
Ordering is counter service, with dine-in, takeout, and delivery available. Parking is free and usually easy to find.
Hours run Tuesday through Sunday, with Mondays off. Friday and Saturday stay open until 10 PM, so a late dinner is doable.
Address: 2666 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505
6. Fratelli Pizzeria
New York-style pizza has a fan club in Bethlehem, and this neighborhood pizzeria is a big reason why. Thin, light, and crispy is the house rule.
The tomato sauce brings plenty of flavor, and the cheese holds up its end. Fresh ingredients show up in combos like sausage with broccoli rabe.
Value is part of the appeal too, with quality pizza that won’t feel like a splurge. Delivery and takeout help when you’d rather eat on the couch.
Pizza isn’t the only draw. Cheesesteaks and stromboli give you options when your group can’t agree.
Fratelli keeps a full vegetarian menu, so meat-free eaters aren’t stuck with one choice. Kids get their own menu, and high chairs are available.
College students and tourists both find their way here. The shop also offers free Wi-Fi and outdoor seating, which never hurts.
Hours are generous, running seven days a week from 11 AM. Friday and Saturday go until 10 PM, and late-night food is part of the deal.
Reservations aren’t accepted, so just walk up and order at the counter. Friday evening is the busiest stretch, while weekday mornings stay calm.
Address: 1230 N New St First Floor, Bethlehem, PA 18018
7. Palumbo’s Italian Eatery
Art on the walls and grandma pizza on the counter make a pretty great combo.
This downtown Harrisburg eatery serves both on North 2nd Street.
The Grandma Pizza Slice is the one to know. Its sauce leans sweet with a little spice, sitting on a crispy crust packed with flavor.
Prefer something thinner? The regular Slice of Pizza keeps things classic, with quality cheese on a flavorful crust.
Then there’s the Stuffed Pizza, for days when one layer just won’t cut it. Add Garlic Knots and you’ve got a feast.
Subs and pasta also fill the menu. The hoagie roll gets high marks, so a sandwich isn’t a bad backup plan.
Ordering happens at the counter, with no table service. It’s a quick, casual stop that works for a solo lunch or a downtown dinner.
Pennsylvania’s capital city has plenty of lunch choices. This one makes a strong case for pizza as the official pick.
Fridays run the longest, from 10:30 AM to 10 PM. Saturdays open at 1 PM, and the shop is closed Sundays.
Street parking can take some patience downtown. Delivery and takeout are solid options if circling the block isn’t your idea of fun.
Address: 104 N 2nd St, Harrisburg, PA 17101
8. Maroni’s Pizza
Tiny pepperoni can carry big personality.
At this longtime family-operated Scranton pizzeria, the pepperoni cups up in the oven and packs more spice than most in the area.
The square pizza is the local favorite. Sauce, cheese, and toppings go on with a generous hand.
Sausage gets just as much love as the pepperoni. Ordering both is a move nobody would blame you for.
Feeling adventurous? Olives and Anchovies is on the menu for the bold eater in your group.
Sandwiches hold their own here too. The Steak and Cheese leads a lineup of classic pizzeria-style options.
The atmosphere is quiet and historic, with a relaxed feel. College students, groups, and families with little ones all fit in, and high chairs are available.
Planning a kid’s birthday? Maroni’s is considered a good spot for one, which makes it more than a quick dinner stop.
Schedule carefully, because hours are short. It’s open Wednesday through Sunday from 11:30 AM to 7:30 PM and closed Mondays and Tuesdays.
There’s no delivery, so plan on dine-in or takeout. Friday afternoons into evenings get the busiest.
Address: 1345 St Ann St, Scranton, PA 18504
9. Faccia Luna Pizzeria
Wood fire and brick oven make a mighty team in State College.
This trattoria turns out pizzas with a crisp, flavorful crust and a smart balance of sauce and cheese.
Pizza is the headliner, but the Italian side of the menu is deep. Bolognese, Five Cheese Ravioli, Spinach and Ricotta Ravioli, and Mushroom Ravioli all compete for attention.
Start with bruschetta, and you get choices. Tomato Bruschetta keeps it classic, while Salmon Bruschetta takes a fancier route.
Fresh Baked Garlic Breadsticks are hard to skip. The Luna Salad offers a fresher option between bites.
College students, families, and visitors all share the room. Kids’ menus, high chairs, and changing tables make family dinners easier.
Service moves fast, which matters when the place gets busy. Friday and Saturday evenings are the peak times.
Reservations aren’t taken, and delivery isn’t offered. Plan on dining in or picking up takeout instead.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 4 to 9 PM, with Sundays off. The parking lot is free but can fill up.
Address: 1229 S Atherton St, State College, PA 16801
10. DeLorenzo’s Tomato Pies
A pizza recipe that survived generations in Trenton now has a Pennsylvania home in Yardley.
DeLorenzo’s Tomato Pies opened here in 2018, carrying forward a family tradition that began in 1947.
The signature tomato pie is the reason to visit. Expect a thin, crisp crust with char around the edges, plus tomato flavor that stands out from ordinary cheese-heavy pizza.
Start with a classic pie before getting creative. Sausage and onion make a hearty combination, while fresh basil adds a lighter touch.
If your group wants something besides pizza, the menu includes salads and antipasti. The arugula salad brings a peppery contrast to those rich slices.
The dining room is bigger than the family’s Robbinsville location, making this a stop for groups. You can order takeout if the plan is pizza back at home.
Lunch is served Tuesday through Friday, with dinner available Tuesday through Sunday. Mondays are closed, so don’t save your craving for then.
It’s a strong detour for anyone exploring Bucks County, especially if you appreciate a restaurant that knows what it does best.
Address: 1707 Yardley Langhorne Rd, Yardley, PA 19067