What Happens When A Maine Chef Known For Italian Food Decides To Open A Patagonian BBQ Steakhouse
A chef who once cooked in Paris, London, Beirut, and Istanbul now cooks steak over local white oak in the Maine woods. That alone made me sit up a little straighter.
He already had a beloved Italian restaurant nearby. Then he felt the pull of the open flame he grew up with in Argentina. So he built a whole new place around it.
The result serves A5 Wagyu ribeye, empanadas, and his grandmother’s bread pudding. The dining room mixes copper, cast iron, crystal, and curved ceilings that feel a bit like an old train station. I’ll admit, that sounds tempting.
What happens when pasta takes a back seat to fire? I’d be curious to find out, and I suspect your stomach would be too.
A Chef Who Took The Long Road Back To His Roots

Germán Lucarelli learned to cook as a kid by helping his grandmother, María Elena, in her kitchen in Argentina. That early start led him on quite a journey.
He worked as a chef and restaurateur in Buenos Aires, Paris, London, Beirut, and Istanbul. Then came Miami and New York before he finally landed in Maine.
In spring 2015, he opened Ports of Italy in Kennebunkport. He called it the fulfillment of a long-held culinary goal, and the restaurant found real success.
Still, something kept tugging at him. He wanted to return to his true roots and the Argentinian tradition of asado, which means cooking over open flames.
That longing became The Lost Fire Grill & Bar, which opened in late August 2018. It marked a bold switch from Italian comfort food to Patagonian grilling.
Plenty of chefs stick with what already works. Lucarelli chose to bet on the food he grew up with instead.
That choice says a lot about him. His cooking philosophy centers on love for the craft, quality ingredients, and consistency.
Authenticity and harmony matter to him too. You can taste a personal story in that kind of approach, and that earns points in my book.
The Fire Is The Real Star Of The Kitchen

Local white oak fuels nearly everything here. The restaurant describes its mission as reviving the lost art of Argentinian cooking, and the name finally makes sense.
Asado is more than a cooking method in Argentina. It’s a whole tradition built around patience, smoke, and gathering people near the heat.
At this steakhouse, that tradition gets a Maine accent. The wood comes from local white oak, which gives the flames a steady burn for meats and vegetables.
An open kitchen lets diners actually see the fire at work. That’s a nice bit of dinner theater, and it beats staring at a closed kitchen door.
Watching flames does something to an appetite. One glance at those coals and suddenly a salad feels like a weak plan.
Wood-fire cooking also asks a lot from the cook. Heat changes constantly, so timing and instinct matter more than any timer on the wall.
That’s where decades of experience come in handy. Lucarelli has cooked on several continents, and this grill is where his whole résumé comes together.
If you like knowing how your dinner gets made, grab a seat with a view. The show is free with every order.
Steaks Big Enough To Need A Game Plan

Thirty-two ounces. That’s the size of the cowboy steak, and it’s not even the fanciest cut on the menu.
The beef lineup here reads like a steak lover’s wish list. You’ll find A5 Wagyu ribeye, a Wagyu tomahawk, skirt steak, and a bone-in ribeye.
The Long Short Rib deserves special attention. It’s a center-cut black Angus rib, and it’s often called out as a signature dish.
Can’t pick just one? A mixed grill for two lets you sample several meats without arm-wrestling your dinner partner for bites.
Here’s some practical advice for these big cuts. Ask your server about the size before ordering, because sharing might be the smarter move.
Every steak gets that white oak treatment. The fire adds smoky depth, so even a simple cut carries a bit of Patagonia with it.
Chimichurri plays a starring role too. The bright herb sauce is an Argentinian classic, and it pairs naturally with anything off the grill.
Steakhouses in Maine usually play second fiddle to lobster shacks. This one makes a strong case that beef deserves a turn in the spotlight.
Start Small With Empanadas And Melty Provolone

Before the steak arrives, the table gets complimentary bread with chimichurri. It’s a friendly little welcome and a hint of what’s coming.
From there, the appetizer list leans into Argentinian favorites. Empanadas come with different fillings, and they’re among the most talked-about starters.
Fried provolone is another tempting pick. In Argentina, grilled or fried provolone is a classic way to kick off an asado.
Lighter options exist too. There’s a shrimp and avocado salad, plus beef carpaccio for anyone who likes their beef thinly sliced and delicate.
Street Corn rounds things out with a casual, crowd-pleasing touch. It’s a smart choice for the table to pass around.
A word of caution, though. The steaks are hefty, so ordering five starters might leave no room for the main event.
A good strategy is to pick two appetizers and share them. That way you get a taste of everything without surrendering before the beef lands.
Honestly, a basket of empanadas and some bubbling provolone could be a meal on its own. Still, I wouldn’t skip the grill if I were you.
Sides That Refuse To Sit Quietly

Yucca fries with a special sauce might steal some attention from the steak. They’re a fun swap for anyone tired of regular potatoes.
Vegetables get the fire treatment here as well. Roasted eggplant and roasted carrots pick up that smoky edge from the wood-burning grill.
Classic steakhouse comfort shows up too. Mashed potatoes and creamed spinach sit on the menu for diners who like the traditional route.
Broccolini adds something green and crisp to the plate. Mushrooms join the lineup for a deeper, earthy flavor next to the beef.
Picking sides is a great chance to mix old and new. Try one familiar favorite and one Argentinian-style option for balance.
Sharing works especially well with sides. Order a few for the table, pass them around, and let everyone find a new favorite.
This approach also matches the spirit of asado. In Argentina, grilling is a group affair, and sharing plates fits right in.
So don’t treat sides as an afterthought. At this Maine steakhouse, they bring their own personality and help make dinner feel complete.
Save Room For Grandma’s Bread Pudding

Some recipes deserve to travel across continents. The bread pudding here is often highlighted as Chef Lucarelli’s grandmother’s recipe, carried from family kitchen to Maine table.
That detail makes dessert feel personal. Remember, his love of cooking started at his grandmother’s side.
Ending a meal with her recipe brings the whole story full circle. It’s sweet in more ways than one.
Italian walnut gelato also appears on the dessert menu. It’s a nod to the chef’s Italian chapter, so his earlier restaurant still gets a little shout-out.
Here’s a helpful tip if you’re too full after the steak. Ordering dessert to go is a perfectly reasonable move.
A box of bread pudding at home later sounds like a fine way to end the night. Nobody needs to know you ate it standing by the fridge.
Whatever you choose, give the sweet side of the menu a fair shot. It carries the most heart in the building.
A Dining Room That Looks Like A Fancy Train Station

Dressy steampunk. That’s how the décor at The Lost Fire Grill & Bar has been described, and it’s more charming than it sounds.
Think distressed wood paired with copper, tin, cast iron, and crystal. Those materials mix rugged and elegant in a way that suits a fire-driven kitchen.
Curved ceilings and booths add another twist. Together, they’re said to evoke an old train station, which feels fitting for a chef who has traveled so far.
The lighting stays soft and warm throughout. Wood accents help the space feel rustic and cozy rather than stiff or formal.
Several distinct rooms divide the restaurant. That layout keeps things from feeling like one giant, noisy hall.
Speaking of formal, you don’t need to dig out a tuxedo. Clean jeans are generally fine, even though the experience leans upscale.
That relaxed dress code takes the pressure off. You can celebrate a big night without feeling like you’re attending a royal wedding.
The bar area also has three large televisions for sports. So yes, you can catch a game while working through a Wagyu ribeye.
Warm Nights Belong Out On The Patio

Fire pits, Adirondack chairs, and a Patagonian grill under the open sky. That’s LUCA, the seasonal patio behind the main restaurant.
LUCA opens during warmer months, roughly mid-May through October. It offers an al fresco take on the same fire-focused cooking.
The patio has its own full bar and comfortable seating. Those Adirondack chairs are a very Maine touch, by the way.
Summer evenings in Maine are short-lived treasures. Spending one beside a fire pit with grilled meat nearby seems like a smart use of the season.
A small heads-up could save you some confusion. When booking, check whether your reservation is indoors or out on the patio.
Both spaces offer something different. Indoors feels cozy and polished, while LUCA leans breezy and casual.
Families celebrating a birthday might love the open-air vibe. Couples might prefer a quiet booth inside.
Either way, the patio shows how much this chef enjoys growing his ideas. LUCA came after the main restaurant, and it adds a whole new reason to visit.
Plan Ahead Before Heading To Cape Porpoise

You’ll find this fire-loving steakhouse at 62 Mills Road, Kennebunkport, ME 04046. It sits in the Cape Porpoise area of Kennebunkport, Maine.
Timing matters here. The Lost Fire Grill & Bar opens Wednesday through Sunday for dinner, starting in the late afternoon.
Mondays and Tuesdays are closed. Learn that before the drive, not after you’ve already pulled in hungry.
Reservations are recommended because the place stays popular. Booking early is your best bet, especially in summer.
Parking is available in a lot, though spaces can be limited. Arriving a few minutes early helps you skip the circling dance.
The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, which is great news for every guest. Takeaway service is offered too, if a night on the couch sounds better.
