11 Wisconsin Supper Clubs Where Every Meal Feels Like A Celebration
Wisconsin has a dining tradition unlike anywhere else in America, and it centers around the beloved supper club.
These aren’t your typical restaurants—they’re throwbacks to a simpler time when getting dressed up for dinner meant something special, and every meal came with a relish tray and Old Fashioned.
I’ll never forget my first supper club experience: walking into a dimly lit room with red leather booths, being greeted like family, and realizing that nowhere else serves prime rib quite like Wisconsin does.
Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary or just craving that nostalgic atmosphere, these 11 supper clubs deliver unforgettable experiences that’ll have you coming back for seconds.
1. Ishnala Supper Club – Lake Delton
Perched on the shores of Mirror Lake, Ishnala offers one of the most breathtaking dining settings you’ll ever experience.
The name means “by itself, alone” in Native American language — though it’s funny, because despite sitting quietly at S2011 Ishnala Road in Lake Delton, this place is never really “alone.”
Trust me, half of Wisconsin seems to show up the same night you do.
Getting there requires a short walk through towering pines, like nature rolled out its own red carpet just for your entrance.
Inside, the menu leans into classic Wisconsin fare — fresh walleye, tender steaks, and cocktails that somehow taste even better when the sunset hits the lake just right.
The rustic wood interior feels like stepping into a vintage postcard from the 1950s, preserved with such charm that you half expect a supper-club crooner to appear out of nowhere and serenade your table.
What truly sets Ishnala apart is how it maintains that authentic old-school magic without ever feeling outdated.
The servers treat you like long-lost friends returning to a lakeside retreat… the kind where someone might hand you a martini and say, “Relax — calories don’t count this far north.”
Make reservations well in advance — and by “in advance,” I mean the kind of early planning normally reserved for weddings and solar eclipses — because everyone wants a piece of this Wisconsin treasure.
2. HobNob Supper Club – Racine
Since 1954, HobNob has been serving up sophistication and seriously good steaks to Racine residents and visitors alike.
Tucked right along the lakeshore at 277 Sheridan Road in Racine, it’s the kind of place where you arrive thinking “fancy dinner” and leave thinking “why don’t I live closer to this?”
Walking through those doors feels like entering a time capsule where quality never goes out of style.
The dimly lit dining room practically whispers elegance with its polished wood and plush seating.
Their signature prime rib is legendary—cooked to absolute perfection and served with all the classic fixings.
But here’s the fun surprise: the seafood selection rivals anything you’d find on the coast, which is pretty impressive for a landlocked Wisconsin establishment.
The relish tray arrives promptly, stacked with pickled vegetables that’ll make you rethink every sad salad you’ve ever eaten.
There’s a reason this supper-club tradition refuses to die.
I once celebrated my parents’ anniversary here, and the staff made them feel like royalty without even a hint of pretension.
That’s the HobNob magic—elegant enough for special occasions but warm enough that you won’t feel judged for ordering a second Old Fashioned.
Speaking of which, the bartenders mix them with the perfect sweet-bitter harmony… the kind of drink that makes you start believing you’re in a 1960s movie.
Just be warned: once you try it, you’ll start casually dropping “277 Sheridan Road” in conversations like you own the place.
3. Buckhorn Supper Club – Milton
Buckhorn sits right on the water, offering that quintessential Wisconsin lake experience alongside mouthwatering meals.
Perched at 11802 N Charley Bluff Road in Milton, it’s one of those places where you pull up, see the lake shimmering, and immediately think, “Ah yes… this is exactly where I’m supposed to be.”
The outdoor patio becomes the hottest ticket in town during summer months, especially when you can arrive by boat and tie up at their dock.
There’s something undeniably cool about cruising up to dinner instead of driving—your car never feels quite as impressive again.
Inside, the atmosphere strikes that perfect balance between casual and celebratory.
The menu doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel—it just makes everything exceptionally well.
Their Friday fish fry draws crowds from miles around, and rightfully so, because the drink-battered cod is crispy perfection.
Weekend prime rib nights pack the house too, creating that classic supper-club buzz where everyone seems just a little extra happy to be there.
What I love most about Buckhorn is how it embraces its lakeside location without ever drifting into tourist-trap territory.
Families gather here for milestone celebrations while couples enjoy romantic dinners at sunset.
The staff knows regulars by name, which adds that warm community feeling Wisconsin is famous for.
It’s the kind of place where you go once… and then accidentally show up again the next weekend, pretending it’s purely coincidence.
4. Lehman’s Supper Club & Lounge – Rice Lake
Up in Rice Lake, Lehman’s has been dishing out comfort and delicious food since way back when.
Tucked at 2911 South Main Street in Rice Lake, it’s the kind of place you spot from the road and immediately think, “Should I stop now or pretend I have self-control?”
Spoiler: stop now. This place understands that supper clubs are about more than just eating—they’re about the entire experience from cocktail to dessert.
The lounge area practically begs you to settle in with a drink before your table’s ready, which is exactly how supper-club dining is meant to unfold.
Honestly, isn’t half the fun just lingering with a cocktail while deciding between steak or… more steak?
Their steaks are hand-cut and grilled exactly to your liking, which sounds simple but makes all the difference.
The salad bar offers more variety than you’d expect, and the hearty entrees pair perfectly with whatever seasonal homemade soup is simmering that week.
They really lean into local ingredients, and you can taste the difference in every spoonful.
Lehman’s maintains that authentic northern Wisconsin hospitality where strangers become friends over shared tables, second helpings, and the occasional debate over whose Old Fashioned is the best.
I’ve watched families celebrate graduations, retirements, and all the little in-between moments inside these walls.
The prices stay refreshingly reasonable despite the generous portions—proof that you don’t need to empty your wallet to eat like royalty.
If you leave hungry, that’s on you… and honestly, how did you even manage that?
5. Wissota High Shores Supper Club – Chippewa Falls
High above Lake Wissota, this supper club delivers views that’ll distract you from your dinner—and that’s saying something, because the food absolutely demands attention.
Perched up at 17985 County Highway X in Chippewa Falls, it’s the kind of place where you walk in, see the panoramic vista, and immediately think, “Wait… am I here for the food or for a spiritual awakening?”
Floor-to-ceiling windows make sure every seat feels like the best seat in the house, no matter the season. Autumn bursts with color, winter sparkles with snow, and summer sunsets?
Pure romantic-movie material.
The kitchen takes pride in preparing each dish with care and consistency.
Their broasted chicken has developed a loyal local following—people swear it’s the best in the state, and honestly, who’s brave enough to argue with Wisconsinites about chicken?
Steaks arrive sizzling, and the seafood selection surprises first-timers with its freshness and variety, especially considering you’re nowhere near an ocean.
What really makes Wissota High Shores special is how they’ve modernized without losing that classic supper-club soul.
The atmosphere stays relaxed and friendly while the presentation has become more polished over the years.
Sunset reservations go fast—ridiculously fast—because there’s nothing quite like watching the sky explode with color while enjoying a perfectly executed meal and excellent company.
And if you find yourself staring out the windows a little too long… don’t worry.
Everyone else is doing the exact same thing.
6. Pinewood Supper Club – Mosinee
Nestled on Half Moon Lake, Pinewood embodies everything wonderful about Wisconsin supper club culture.
The moment you step inside, the scent of grilled steaks and the sound of friendly chatter tell you you’re somewhere special.
Sitting cozily at 1208 Half Moon Lake Drive in Mosinee, it’s the kind of spot where you walk in and immediately think, “Yes… this is exactly the Wisconsin energy I came for.”
This isn’t a place trying to be trendy—it’s a place that’s been getting it right for decades.
Their menu reads like a greatest-hits collection of supper club classics, executed with skill and served with genuine warmth.
The prime rib on weekends disappears quickly, so arrive early or call ahead to ensure they don’t run out.
Their fish options showcase Wisconsin’s freshwater bounty, especially the walleye that tastes like it practically jumped from lake to plate—politely, of course, because this is Wisconsin.
I appreciate how Pinewood keeps prices family-friendly while never compromising on quality or portion size. The staff treats everyone like regulars, whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth.
During summer, the lakeside setting becomes even more appealing as boats glide past and laughter drifts across the water from the outdoor seating area.
Honestly, if relaxation had a mailing address, I’m pretty sure it would be this one.
7. Schwarz’s Supper Club – New Holstein
Schwarz’s has been a New Holstein institution for generations, serving up hearty meals and warm hospitality to grateful diners.
Nestled right at W1688 Sheboygan Road in New Holstein, it’s the kind of place where you pull into the parking lot and instantly think, “Yes… this is where the good food lives.”
This is the kind of supper club where the owner might stop by your table to chat, and you leave feeling like you’ve somehow acquired three new friends and one distant cousin.
The building itself looks like it stepped out of a 1960s postcard, which only adds to its nostalgic charm.
The kitchen specializes in generous portions of perfectly prepared classics—think juicy steaks, golden fried chicken, and seafood that will genuinely surprise you with its quality.
Their relish tray is legendary, loaded with pickled vegetables, fresh veggies, and spreads that could easily qualify as a light meal… or a heavy snack, depending on your Wisconsin personality.
The salad bar offers crisp, fresh options that balance beautifully with the rich main courses that follow.
What keeps people coming back to Schwarz’s isn’t just the food—it’s the atmosphere of genuine hospitality that permeates every interaction.
Celebrations happen here regularly because the staff knows exactly how to make occasions feel special without any fuss or formality.
This is Wisconsin dining at its most authentic and satisfying—the kind that makes you wonder why every place isn’t run like this.
8. Chissy’s Pub & Grille – Waldo
Tucked away in tiny Waldo, Chissy’s proves that great supper clubs don’t need big-city crowds to shine.
Located at 215 State Highway 28 in Waldo, it’s the kind of place you pass once and instantly think, “Yep, that’s where the good food is.”
The menu hits all the classics—perfectly cooked steaks, a Friday fish fry that could win trophies, and specials that show off the kitchen’s skill.
Using local ingredients gives every dish a fresh, genuine flavor.
The pub side is relaxed, while the dining room offers that true supper club feel.
And despite the name sounding like a casual bar, Chissy’s delivers the full experience: generous portions, friendly service, and that small-town warmth that tells you locals practically treat it as their second home.
9. Five O’Clock Steakhouse – Milwaukee
In the heart of Milwaukee, Five O’Clock Steakhouse has been serving unforgettable steaks since 1946.
Located at 2416 West State Street, it’s the kind of place you walk into and instantly think, “Yes… this is real steakhouse territory.”
Hand-cut steaks are grilled over an open flame, giving that perfect char on the outside and juicy center inside.
The sides stay classic and comforting — mashed potatoes, onion rings, all done just right.
Their martinis are famously strong, the kind that make you sit up a little straighter.
What makes Five O’Clock special is how proudly it stays old-school: retro décor, warm service, and zero interest in chasing trends.
Locals and celebrities pack the place nightly, all after the same thing — a perfectly cooked steak that proves some traditions never need updating.
10. Toby’s Supper Club – Madison
On Madison’s south side, Toby’s has been satisfying diners since 1970 with steady quality and genuine warmth.
Sitting at 3717 South Dutch Mill Road in Madison, it’s the kind of place where you walk in and immediately think, “Yep, they’ve been doing this right for a long time.”
The menu delivers all the supper-club essentials, prepared with real care.
Their weekend prime rib is carved tableside — a little bit of old-school theater that never gets old.
The seafood selection is surprisingly strong too, especially the lobster tail that practically begs to be paired with a perfectly grilled steak.
What keeps Toby’s special is its consistency and heart.
Longtime staff remember regulars and their favorite orders, creating that personal touch chain restaurants only dream about.
Trends come and go, but Toby’s stays Toby’s — and Madison diners wouldn’t have it any other way.
11. Del-Bar – Lake Delton
Since 1943, Del-Bar has been wowing Wisconsin Dells visitors with spectacular food and unforgettable atmosphere.
Located at 800 Wisconsin Dells Parkway in Wisconsin Dells, it’s the kind of place you pass and immediately think, “Ah, so this is where all the important people eat.”
And honestly, with its mid-century architecture that practically begs to be photographed, you wouldn’t be wrong.
The kitchen prepares everything from scratch using time-tested recipes and top-quality ingredients.
Their steaks are aged to perfection and grilled with the kind of confidence that only eight decades of practice can give.
Even the relish tray is an experience—overflowing with house-made pickles, crisp vegetables, and spreads that could very well steal the spotlight from your entrée.
Del-Bar manages to feel both historic and timeless, a rare feat in a tourist-heavy destination like the Dells.
The service is polished but warm, the atmosphere elegant but never intimidating.
I’ve celebrated countless special occasions here, and every visit reminds me why Del-Bar has remained a Wisconsin institution for over 80 years.
It’s supper-club dining elevated to an art form… with just enough flair to make you wonder if you should’ve worn nicer shoes.