6 Wisconsin Supper Clubs Where The Menu Hasn’t Changed In Years

Growing up in Wisconsin, supper clubs were the backdrop of every family celebration worth remembering.

These nostalgic dining establishments aren’t just restaurants – they’re time capsules of culinary tradition where relish trays, brandy old fashioneds, and prime rib specials reign supreme.

I’ve personally toured dozens of these beloved institutions across the Badger State, and found something magical about places where the menus have remained virtually unchanged for generations.

1. Buckhorn Supper Club (Milton)

Buckhorn Supper Club (Milton)
© travel/food

Perched on the shores of Lake Koshkonong, Buckhorn’s weathered wooden sign welcomed me like an old friend last summer. The vintage neon still glows exactly as it did when my grandparents dined here in the 1960s. Their legendary prime rib arrives on the same blue-rimmed plates they’ve used for over half a century, accompanied by those impossibly crispy hash browns that somehow maintain their texture throughout your entire meal.

The recipe hasn’t changed since 1931. What struck me most was the relish tray – that beautiful, simple assortment of raw vegetables, pickled beets, and cheese spread that appears before you even order. The bartender still hand-muddies old fashioneds with the ceremonial precision of a watchmaker.

2. Duck Inn Supper Club

Duck Inn Supper Club
© Lake Geneva Regional News

Nestled in the rolling hills, Duck Inn Supper Club is a cherished relic of dining history. Known for its timeless ambiance, the club offers an array of traditional dishes that capture the essence of a bygone era. Patrons are greeted with the comforting aroma of roast duck, a signature dish that’s been on the menu since the club’s inception.

The intimate setting, with its wood-paneled walls and vintage decor, transports diners back in time, ensuring each visit is a nostalgic journey. Regulars swear by the club’s unwavering commitment to quality and tradition.

As stories are shared over Old Fashioneds, the Duck Inn Supper Club remains a cornerstone of culinary heritage in Wisconsin’s landscape.

3. Ishnala Supper Club

Ishnala Supper Club
© www.ishnala.com

Located in the heart of Wisconsin Dells, Ishnala Supper Club is a place where history and nature blend seamlessly. Nestled in the woods, overlooking Mirror Lake, this club offers more than just a dining experience. Guests are greeted by a rustic log cabin ambiance, complete with warm fireplaces and vintage decor. The menu has remained untouched for decades, featuring classics like prime rib and Old Fashioned cocktails.

For over 60 years, Ishnala has been a haven for those seeking a taste of nostalgia. The stunning natural surroundings only add to its timeless charm, making every visit a memorable one.

4. HobNob Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge (Racine, WI)

HobNob Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge (Racine, WI)
© Tripadvisor

At HobNob, nostalgia fills the air as the menu hasn’t changed in decades. Stepping inside is like entering a time capsule of culinary delight. The dimly lit dining room, adorned with vintage decor, creates a cozy atmosphere that invites you to linger.

Signature cocktails, a staple of HobNob, bring a taste of the past to each sip. The relish tray, a beloved tradition in Wisconsin supper clubs, welcomes guests with a nostalgic touch. Whether it’s the prime rib or the Friday fish fry, each dish echoes the flavors of yesteryears.

Did you know? HobNob’s charm and menu have remained unchanged since the 1950s, offering both locals and visitors a taste of history.

5. Schwarz’s Supper Club (New Holstein / St. Anna, WI)

Schwarz’s Supper Club (New Holstein / St. Anna, WI)
© Family Destinations Guide

In the quaint town of New Holstein, Schwarz’s Supper Club stands as a beacon of tradition. Established decades ago, this beloved establishment has not wavered in its culinary offerings. Guests are greeted with a warm, nostalgic ambiance, where wood-paneled walls and vintage decor evoke a sense of timelessness.

Locals and visitors alike flock here for their renowned prime rib, cooked to perfection and served with all the classic sides. The menu remains a tribute to the hearty, comforting dishes that have satisfied generations. Schwarz’s is more than a dining spot; it’s a cherished piece of local history.

6. Roepke’s Village Inn Supper Club (Chilton, WI)

Roepke’s Village Inn Supper Club (Chilton, WI)
© Green Bay Press-Gazette

Nestled in the heart of Chilton, Roepke’s Village Inn Supper Club offers a timeless dining experience. Known for its rustic charm and warm hospitality, this beloved establishment has been a cornerstone of the community for decades.

The menu, a testament to tradition, features classic Wisconsin dishes such as prime rib and fried fish. Patrons can enjoy their meals in a cozy setting filled with vintage decor and wooden interiors that exude a nostalgic vibe.

Roepke’s is more than just a place to eat; it’s a gathering spot for friends and families to create lasting memories over cherished recipes.