13 Ohio Pumpkin Treat Stops Perfect For A Halloween Weekend Drive
One Ohio bakery shows off a pumpkin pie that measures 6 feet across and weighs more than 400 pounds. I had to read that twice.
The same shop once made an 18-foot pumpkin pie back in 2005. During its hometown festival, the ovens run around the clock to keep up with donut orders.
That got me curious about where else pumpkin gets the royal treatment around here.
I found fried pies in Amish Country, vegan donuts by the lake, and a croissant-donut mashup dusted in fall spice.
So grab a full tank and an empty back seat for the boxes. Which stop would you hit first?
1. Lindsey’s Bakery
A pie the size of a kiddie pool lives here during festival season. The bakery calls itself home of the World’s Largest Pumpkin Pie.
That giant measures 6 feet across and tops 400 pounds. It sits on display inside during the famous Circleville Pumpkin Show.
The real star, though, might be smaller. Lindsey’s pumpkin donuts are cakey, lightly glazed, and sold all year long.
Their story started with the founders’ grandfather, who first made them only for the festival. During show week, the bakery fries them around the clock and sells over 100,000.
Lindsey’s opened in 1950, and grandsons of the founders run it today. Items are made from scratch and never frozen, which explains the steady loyalty.
Don’t skip the rest of the case either. Cookies, cinnamon buns, cream donuts, and cakes all share the shelves.
Hours run Tuesday through Saturday, 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. Saturday mornings tend to be the busiest stretch, so arrive early if you can.
Short on time? There’s a drive-thru, so you can grab a dozen without unbuckling.
Free street parking works too if you’d rather wander downtown Circleville afterward.
Address: 127 W Main St, Circleville, OH 43113
2. Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery
Few bakeries come with a wagon ride to a pumpkin patch. In the fall, this Holmes County farm offers exactly that.
Horse-drawn rides circle the property or roll out to the patch. Amish buggy rides are also available for a fee.
Kids usually head straight for the petting zoo. Grown-ups tend to drift toward the bakery counter instead.
Here’s your pumpkin prize: pumpkin pies join the bakery’s famous fried pies among the fall treats worth looking for.
Want something to bake later? Ask the staff about available take-home pie options.
Your oven does the work, and your kitchen gets the credit.
Beyond sweets, you’ll find fresh fruits and vegetables, snacks, meats, and cheeses. Jams, jellies, and pickles round out the shelves nicely.
The farm is known for award-winning pumpkins, too. That makes it a fun place to admire some serious gourds.
Plan around Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. It’s closed Sundays, so don’t save it for the drive home.
Saturdays get busy from morning to afternoon. A free lot helps, and State Route 557 makes the drive itself a treat.
Address: 5452 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654
3. Kauffman’s Country Bakery
Two brothers opened this bakery in the spring of 1992. Family recipes still guide plenty of the baking today.
October brings a full pumpkin lineup. Think pumpkin whoopie pies sold in four-packs and pumpkin rolls in six-packs.
Pumpkin pie comes in 6-inch and 9-inch sizes. Pumpkin spice donuts join the October specials too.
Iced pumpkin donuts have earned real fans here. Pair one with an apple fritter and call it balance.
The shelves go well beyond pumpkin. Breads, cookies, pastries, cream sticks, and fry pies all make a strong case.
Most ingredients are sourced locally, and many Amish women work in the kitchen. That hometown touch shows up in the menu.
An on-site cafe serves coffee, milkshakes, paninis, subs, and breakfast sandwiches. Bulk foods and souvenirs are also for sale.
Weekend timing is friendly here. Saturday hours run 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Sundays run 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. from May through December.
Saturday afternoons get crowded, while Sunday is calmer. The free lot sits right on the scenic US-62 corridor near Berlin.
Address: 4357 US-62, Millersburg, OH 44654
4. Miller’s Bakery
Bring cash and a sense of direction. This little Amish bakery sits along a winding township road in Holmes County.
The detour pays off quickly. Pumpkin-themed cookies are a seasonal pick for anyone chasing fall flavors.
Donuts carry much of the fame here. Glazed rings, cream-filled long johns, and black raspberry jam-filled donuts all show up.
Blueberry-filled donuts and apple fritters are worth a look too. Tarts and cookies round things out.
Miller’s specializes in homemade donuts and fruit-filled tarts. So a mixed box makes a lot of sense.
There’s no dine-in, so plan on eating in the car. Honestly, a country road view beats most tables anyway.
Hours run Monday through Saturday, 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. Sunday is closed, like many Amish Country businesses.
Saturday mornings bring the biggest rush. Weekday middays tend to be quieter if your trip allows it.
Remember the cash-only rule before you leave the main road. Ohio’s backroads aren’t known for ATMs.
A free parking lot keeps the stop easy. Grab your pumpkin cookies and keep cruising the hills.
Address: 4250 Township Hwy 356, Millersburg, OH 44654
5. Resch’s Bakery
Over a century of baking, and the family just got a bigger kitchen. Resch’s moved to Gahanna in October 2025.
The story began in 1912 on East Livingston Avenue in Columbus. German immigrants Wilhelm and Frank Resch started it all.
Six generations later, it’s still family-owned. The new space gives the team far more room for production.
Fall brings the pumpkin donuts. They’re soft, spiced cake donuts, often glazed or topped with cream cheese icing.
Around Halloween, the case gets even more festive. Look for pumpkin iced cookies, pumpkin cupcakes, and pumpkin-designed decorated cakes.
Pies are part of the mix as well. A pumpkin pie makes a smart souvenir for whoever stayed home.
Classic picks like French crullers, apple fritters, and cheese danish hold steady year-round. Everything in that lineup is scratch-made.
There’s no dine-in or restroom, so treat it as a quick grab-and-go. A free parking lot makes that easy.
Saturday hours run 7 a.m. to 4 p.m., and Sunday is closed. Weekday mornings are usually calmer than Saturday.
Address: 150 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna, OH 43230
6. Young’s Jersey Dairy
Ice cream and pumpkin picking on the same afternoon? This working dairy farm outside Yellow Springs makes that combo possible.
Fall visits can include choosing your own pumpkin through October 25, 2026. After that, pumpkin ice cream and cinnamon sugar pumpkin donut holes still give you a seasonal reason to stop.
The ice cream menu runs deep. The Double Buckeye Sundae and Buckeye Bull Shake give a nod to Ohio pride.
Hungry for something savory? Deep fried cheddar cheese curds and bacon cheeseburgers are on the menu too.
Young’s also has a cheese store and a restaurant. Mini golf, batting cages, and a driving range keep energy levels in check.
Long lines are common on weekend afternoons. Online ordering helps you skip some of that waiting.
There’s a drive-thru as well, plus curbside pickup. Dogs are welcome outside if your pup is riding along.
Saturday hours run 9 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday closes at 9 p.m., so evening stops work fine.
The free on-site lot keeps things simple. Mornings are the quietest time to visit.
Address: 6880 Springfield Xenia Rd, Yellow Springs, OH 45387
7. Gardner Pie Co
Pumpkin latte pie. Yes, someone put your favorite fall drink flavor into a crust, and Akron is better for it.
Gardner Pie Co sticks to what the name promises. Pies are the whole point here.
Classic pumpkin pie is the traditional fall pick. Plenty of families have grabbed one here for Thanksgiving over the years.
The shop once operated on Van Buren in nearby Barberton. Today it sits on Logan Parkway in Akron.
Crust gets plenty of attention from fans. So does the cherry pie, if you need a second flavor.
Timing matters on a weekend drive. Saturday hours run only from 8 a.m. to noon.
That means a morning start is your best plan. Sunday is closed.
Weekdays stretch from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. If your trip begins on Friday, that’s another window.
There’s no restroom on site, so plan stops accordingly. A free parking lot makes pickup quick.
Take a pie or two for the road. Just keep them level on the seat.
Address: 191 Logan Pkwy, Akron, OH 44319
8. Royal Donut
Early birds, this one’s for you. Royal Donut opens at 5 a.m.
Tuesday through Saturday.
The pumpkin donuts here carry a real reputation. They’re pumpkin cake donuts, and they’re among the shop’s best-known items.
Apple fritters are another favorite. Huge cinnamon rolls also earn a spot in the box.
You’ll find a lineup of classic donuts too. Filled options and variety donuts keep choices easy.
Coffee and tea are on hand, and the coffee gets good marks. That makes a sunrise start a lot friendlier.
Counter service keeps things moving fast. There’s seating for a quick snack and a restroom, too.
Prefer to stay in the car? A drive-through window has you covered.
Saturday hours end at 3 p.m., and Sunday and Monday are closed. Plan your Greater Cleveland loop with that in mind.
Saturday mornings are the busiest time. Arriving close to opening is a smart move for pumpkin fans.
A free lot and free street parking help. Parma sits close to Cleveland, so it slots into many routes.
Address: 5759 State Rd, Parma, OH 44134
9. The Vegan Doughnut Company
No eggs, no dairy, and no shortage of fans. Lakewood’s plant-based donut shop proves that pumpkin season welcomes every diet.
The pumpkin spice donut is the fall pick. It’s known for being soft and pillowy, which is exactly what you want.
The full menu leans creative and gourmet. Old fashioned and blueberry cake donuts are part of the regular lineup.
It’s a family business with a big selection. The shop itself is small, clean, and bright.
Plan to take your treats to go. There’s no dine-in seating and no restroom.
That works fine on a lake drive, though. Detroit Avenue makes for an easy cruise near Lake Erie.
Weekend hours run 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. on both Saturday and Sunday. Wednesday through Friday opens an hour earlier.
Monday and Tuesday are closed. Mark that before you set your route.
Mornings tend to be busy across open days. Go early for the best shot at seasonal flavors.
Parking options include a free lot and street spots. Grab a box for friends who swear they don’t eat vegan.
Address: 14811 Detroit Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107
10. Donut Land
Midnight donut run on a Friday? Donut Land stays open 24 hours from Tuesday through Saturday.
That schedule fits a Halloween weekend perfectly. Late-night candy wears off, but fresh donuts don’t judge.
Pumpkin-flavored treats pop up in the fall. They give you a seasonal reason to stop in Medina County.
Apple fritters are the signature item. Cherry cake, strawberry-filled, and cinnamon rolls also make the menu.
Ohio fans should look for the Buckeye donut. Peanut butter and chocolate fans, you know what to do.
Donuts are made fresh daily. The shop also offers custom donut cakes for parties.
There’s seating and counter service, so you can eat on the spot. The setting is casual and family-friendly.
Sunday hours run from midnight to 4 p.m. Monday is closed, so plan around that.
Friday evenings and Saturdays bring the biggest crowds. Monday night is quiet, mostly because the doors are shut.
A free lot sits right on Center Road. Some folks happily drive down from Cleveland for a box.
Address: 3871 Center Rd, Brunswick, OH 44212
11. Starlight Doughnut Lab
A pimento cheese donut has appeared on the menu here. That tells you this Norwood lab enjoys a good experiment.
Flavors rotate monthly, and the results get inventive. Sweet, savory, and vegan options all share the counter.
Fall can bring a pumpkin roll donut. It’s earned some very big praise from pumpkin lovers.
Brioche-style donuts show up often. So do surprises like an everything bagel version.
Vegan picks aren’t an afterthought either. A vegan Boston cream and a vegan raspberry have been part of the rotating lineup.
The cream-filled donuts have a strong following. Road trippers passing through Cincinnati make a point to stop.
Hours are tight, so plan carefully. Thursday and Friday run 8 a.m. to 2 p.m., or until sold out.
Saturday and Sunday run 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., or until sold out. Monday through Wednesday is closed.
There’s no restroom inside the shop. Coffee is available and gets good marks.
Street parking is available along Carter Avenue, though spaces can be limited.
The Wood Bar nearby allows customers to use its lot during the bar’s closed hours. Check the monthly menu before you go, since flavors change.
Address: 4603 Carter Ave, Norwood, OH 45212
12. Holtman’s Donut Shop
Open from 5 a.m. to 10 p.m., seven days a week. Holtman’s might be the easiest stop on this list to fit in.
That schedule works for sunrise starts and late returns alike. No need to race the clock on Sunday.
Pumpkin donuts are the seasonal draw. They’ve earned plenty of love around the holidays.
The case holds a wide spread of homemade donuts. Fresh brownies and pastries share the space too.
Lines can stretch outside the shop at times. Popularity like that usually means good things.
Friday and Saturday evenings tend to be busiest. Early mornings during the week are much calmer.
You can dine in if you want a breather. A restroom is available, which every road trip appreciates.
Coffee is on the menu as well. Pair it with a pumpkin donut and you’ve got a fine breakfast.
The shop sits along State Route 28 in Loveland. That’s handy for drives around the east side of Cincinnati.
A free parking lot makes stopping simple. Grab extras, since snacks vanish fast in a car.
Address: 1399 OH-28, Loveland, OH 45140
13. Marcella’s Doughnuts & Bakery
Can’t pick between a croissant and a donut? Marcella’s answers with the Pumpkin Spice Croughnut.
That flaky mashup is the fall highlight here. It blends layered pastry with donut fun and a dose of spice.
Gourmet doughnuts fill the rest of the case. Cronuts are a specialty too.
Apple fritters make a strong backup choice. The donuts here are known for their big size.
Treats are handmade, and the team is known for being friendly. That makes a quick stop feel easy.
Saturday hours run 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. That leaves room for a late snack after a day of leaf peeping.
Sunday is shorter, from 7 a.m. to noon. Morning visits are your best bet on that day.
Monday is closed, so plan your Ohio loop accordingly. Tuesday through Friday opens at 5:30 a.m.
A restroom is available, and coffee is on the menu. Orange juice is there too for the kids.
The free on-site lot sits along Clough Pike. It’s a sweet way to wrap up a pumpkin-packed weekend.
Address: 545 Clough Pike #400, Cincinnati, OH 45244