10 Ohio Pizzerias Where You Can Order An Absurdly Massive Pie

I always thought ordering a large pizza was pretty straightforward.

Then I discovered that some Ohio pizzerias make pies so enormous that getting them home might be the biggest challenge.

Seriously, what do you do when your pizza is 30 inches wide and your back seat barely has room for groceries? Apparently, that’s a problem worth solving when dinner looks this tempting.

The more I looked into Ohio’s giant pizzas, the more ridiculous the sizes became. One restaurant even cuts its massive creation into 64 pieces, which should keep everyone at the table busy.

I found ten pizzerias that take their large orders very seriously. If you’re planning a pizza night with friends, you might want to measure your car first.

1. J-Cups Pizza, Toledo

Thirty inches of pizza is not a meal. It is an event.

J-Cups Pizza in Toledo bakes the Gigantor, and the name is honestly a little modest. This 30-inch beast sits near the top of the list for the largest pies in the whole state.

My first look at it made me laugh out loud, mostly because the box seemed wider than my kitchen table.

Size is only half the fun here. The menu features more than 40 specialty pizza varieties, so picking a flavor can take longer than eating a slice.

I suggest bringing a group with mixed tastes and splitting the decision. Someone always wants classic pepperoni, and someone else will lobby for the wild specialty with toppings you never thought belonged together.

Here is my practical tip. Call ahead if you plan to order the Gigantor for a party, since a pie this big takes time and oven space.

Also, measure your back seat before you leave home. A 30-inch box does not fold, and it will not politely squeeze between car seats.

Kids especially love this one, because watching an adult wrestle a box this size is pure entertainment.

Leftovers are almost guaranteed, which means breakfast is basically handled for the next two days.

Address: 4843 N Detroit Ave, Toledo, OH 43612

2. The Cove Pizza Company, Ontario

A restaurant warning that your pizza might not fit in your car is my favorite kind of warning.

The Cove Pizza Company in Ontario serves the Enormous Cove, a 30-inch New York-style pie with real swagger. The crew is not joking about that car thing either.

A buddy of mine picked one up in a compact sedan. He ended up driving home with the box angled across the passenger seat like a very cheesy surfboard.

Beyond the size, the pizzas here are handmade with generous toppings. The thin, foldable slices have that classic New York feel, which makes the huge pieces easier to manage.

Fold, bite, repeat. That is the whole strategy.

The casual setting fits the spirit of the place perfectly. Nobody here expects fancy manners when a slice is longer than your forearm.

If you are passing through the Mansfield area, this stop makes a fun detour. It works great for road trip crews who need something more memorable than a gas station snack.

Plan for a crowd of hungry people, or plan for a fridge full of slices. Either outcome is a win in my book.

Just remember to clear your seats before you drive over.

Address: 325 1/2 Shelby-Ontario Rd, Ontario, OH 44906

3. D’Tutanelli’s Pizza, Amherst

Ten slices or sixty pieces is the big choice at this Amherst favorite. Both options feel slightly ridiculous in the best way.

D’Tutanelli’s Pizza makes the 29-inch Pizza Gigante, and the cutting style changes the whole experience.

Go with the 10 New York-style slices if your crew likes big, floppy pieces that need two hands. Choose the 60 party-cut pieces if you are feeding little kids, a soccer team, or guests who like to graze.

I picked the party cut for a family gathering once. The tiny squares vanished so fast that I only managed three, and I was the one who paid.

Lesson learned. Grab your share early.

The menu also offers creative specialty pizzas, so you are not stuck with plain cheese on a pie this large. Mixing a familiar flavor with something bolder keeps everyone happy.

The atmosphere leans warm and family-friendly, which makes it easy to bring the whole clan along. Grandparents, toddlers, and teens can all find something to enjoy.

My advice is to decide on the cut before you call. It saves time and avoids a family debate on speakerphone.

Sixty pieces sounds like plenty, until it suddenly is not.

Address: 103 Milan Ave, Amherst, OH 44001

4. Chet & Matt’s Pizza, Sandusky

Sixty-four pieces from a single pizza is a number that deserves respect.

Chet & Matt’s Pizza in Sandusky serves the King Kong, a 29-inch pie sliced into that wild count. The name fits, because this thing rules the table the moment it lands.

Sandusky already draws crowds for summer fun near the lake. After a long day outside, a pizza this big feels like the right reward for a tired, hungry group.

You can customize the King Kong with specialty combinations or pick your own toppings. I like going half and half, which keeps the picky eaters and the adventurous eaters from arguing.

Here is the key tip. Order ahead.

The restaurant recommends advance ordering, and trust me, you do not want to stand around hungry while a giant pie gets built from scratch.

Square pieces make this pizza a party champion. Guests can grab one, chat, and come back for another without committing to a huge slice.

Kids treat it like a counting game, too. Someone in my group tried to track every piece and lost count around twenty.

Bring napkins, bring friends, and bring a big appetite.

Address: 1013 E Strub Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870

5. SDS Pizza, Oxford

College students know a good deal when they see one. Miami University students have been proving that at SDS Pizza for years.

This longtime Oxford shop sits close to campus and offers the 29-inch Giant Party Pizza. The best part is that it carries the same generous toppings as the regular pies, so nobody gets shortchanged.

I visited during a busy weekend, and the place had a lively campus energy. Groups of friends kept walking out with boxes so wide they had to turn sideways at the door.

Watching that happen never gets old.

The giant round pies are a go-to choice for student parties, study group nights, and dorm celebrations. Parents visiting for a weekend also seem to love treating a crowd of roommates.

A friend from South Carolina came up for a campus tour, and this was the pizza we ordered afterward. She still talks about it more than the tour itself.

My tip is to plan your pickup time wisely. Weekend evenings get busy, especially during big campus events.

Splitting the cost among a group makes this one of the friendliest ways to feed a lot of people in town.

Final exams are tough, but leftover SDS slices make them a little easier.

Address: 7 E Chestnut St, Oxford, OH 45056

6. Taranto’s Pizzeria, Lewis Center

Dinosaurs roam Lewis Center, and they are made of dough.

Taranto’s Pizzeria serves the Tarantosaurus, a 29-inch pie with a name that makes kids grin before the box even opens. It has earned a reputation for feeding big groups with just one order.

My nephew asked if the pizza would roar. It did not, but he roared at it anyway, which felt fair.

Fun names are great, but flavor matters most. Taranto’s uses freshly prepared dough and house-made sauce, so the crust has real character and the sauce tastes bright instead of bland.

The specialty toppings add even more appeal. You can keep things simple or go bold, depending on who is gathered around the table.

This pie makes a smart pick for team parties, especially youth sports groups. One box can handle a whole crew of hungry players after a long game.

For the smoothest experience, call ahead and give the kitchen some time. A giant pie with fresh dough is worth a little patience.

Bring a table with plenty of space, too. The Tarantosaurus likes room to stretch out.

Leftovers are practically guaranteed, so tomorrow’s breakfast might already be sorted.

Address: 1282 E Powell Rd, Lewis Center, OH 43035

7. Creno’s Pizza, Heath

Party planners in central Ohio have a secret weapon. It is called the Big Kahuna.

Creno’s Pizza offers this 29-inch pie, built specifically for parties and big gatherings. The Heath location is one of the chain’s established storefronts, and it serves a loyal local crowd.

I first heard about the Big Kahuna at a graduation party. Someone set the box down, and every guest drifted toward it like the cake had been cancelled.

Honestly, nobody missed the cake.

The pizza itself keeps things friendly and familiar, which is exactly what you want for a mixed crowd. Aunts, coworkers, and little cousins can all find a slice they enjoy.

Now for the practical part. Confirm that the Big Kahuna is available when you place your order, since availability can vary.

A quick phone call ahead of time saves you from surprises on party day. It also gives the kitchen a heads-up to prepare for something this large.

Pickup takes a little planning, too. Bring a vehicle with a flat surface, such as a cleared back seat or a cargo area.

The Big Kahuna turns any ordinary get-together into a celebration worth remembering.

Address: 789 Hebron Rd, Heath, OH 43056

8. Mama Mary’s Pizza, Holland

Four large pizzas in one is the math behind Mama Mary’s biggest pie.

This family-owned Holland pizzeria bakes the Colossal Pizza, a 28-inch New York-style thin crust cut into 12 gigantic slices. The restaurant says it equals roughly four standard large pizzas.

I love a family-owned spot because it usually feels personal. Mama Mary’s has that warm, neighborly vibe where you feel welcome from the first hello.

The thin crust is the real star. Even with slices this big, the crust stays crisp enough to hold toppings without turning floppy.

Each slice is a serious commitment, though. My first one hung off the edge of a dinner plate, and I needed a second plate as backup.

Twelve slices make sharing easy for a group of six to eight people. Big eaters might go for two, while lighter eaters can stop at one and still feel full.

Ordering one Colossal can also be simpler than juggling four separate boxes. Fewer boxes means less clutter and less trash to clean up afterward.

Holland sits just outside Toledo, so this makes a handy pick for northwest Ohio gatherings.

Mama would be proud of your clean plate.

Address: 7130 Airport Hwy, Suite 5, Holland, OH 43528

9. Joseppi’s Pizza, Columbus

Some pizza places come and go. Joseppi’s Pizza has stuck around long enough to become a Columbus-area institution.

The Lincoln Village location on the west side serves 28-inch Party Pizzas. These are among the largest options on the menu, and they are made for sharing.

Choices are a big strength here. You can go with pepperoni, deluxe, vegetarian, or other specialty combinations, so even a picky group can agree.

The deluxe is my personal pick. It comes piled high, and every bite tastes like someone actually cared about the toppings.

A cousin visiting from South Carolina tried the vegetarian version with me. She claimed she would only eat one slice, then quietly finished three.

That is the Joseppi’s effect.

Long-running local spots like this often carry a sense of comfort. Families who grew up eating here now bring their own kids, and that kind of loyalty says a lot about the food.

For a game night or office lunch, a Party Pizza keeps things easy. One order covers a crowd without a complicated plan.

Call ahead, pick your combo, and let the west side handle dinner.

Address: 4764 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228

10. Guys Pizza, Cleveland Heights

A single slice longer than a foot is a beautiful thing to hold.

Guys Pizza in Cleveland Heights serves The New Yorker, a 24-inch round pie cut into eight oversized slices. Each piece stretches more than 12 inches, which turns lunch into a balancing act.

The Coventry neighborhood has a fun, artsy personality, and this pizzeria fits right in. Grabbing a slice here and wandering the street afterward makes for a great afternoon.

My first New Yorker slice nearly flopped onto my shoes. A friendly local showed me the classic fold, and that trick saved my sneakers.

Fold it lengthwise. Your shoes will thank you.

Guys Pizza has another giant option, too. Full-sheet pizzas come cut into 32 pieces, and they work perfectly for office parties, club meetings, or big family events.

The round New Yorker is ideal for a small group that loves big slices. The full sheet is better for a crowd that prefers smaller squares.

Picking between them depends on your headcount and how much you enjoy dramatic slice moments.

Either way, this Cleveland Heights favorite ends our pizza road trip on a very tall, very cheesy note.

Address: 1838 Coventry Rd, Cleveland Heights, OH 44118