How to Make the Best Orange Creamsicle Cookies

Have you ever had a taste of childhood nostalgia like no other? Orange creamsicle cookies are the perfect mix of flavor and comfort, with a modern twist. Not only are they beyond delicious, they are also surprisingly simple to make! In this blog post, we’ll walk you through a step-by-step recipe for the perfect orange creamsicle cookies.

If you love the taste of orange juice and vanilla ice cream, you’ll find these orange creamsicle cookies will become one of your favorite desserts. They’re relatively easy to make, so the whole family can enjoy them together.

Can you freeze creamsicle cookies?

Yes, and because they freeze so well, you can take some to work to share with your co-workers or friends on any special occasion—without having to go out and buy more!

Best of all, they only contain four ingredients! If you want to get fancy, though, feel free to add some sprinkles on top or even drizzle some melted chocolate over the finished product.

How to Make the Best Orange Creamsicle Cookies

Ingredients

1 box vanilla cake mix

1/3 cup vegetable oil

2 eggs

Zest of one orange

Orange gel food coloring

Granulated sugar in a shallow bowl

Powdered sugar in a shallow bowl

Yields: 24

Directions

In a large bowl, mix together cake mix, oil, eggs and orange zest.

Once the cookie dough forms, add one dot of gel food coloring.

Mix until cookie dough is completely colored.

Wrap the cookie dough in plastic and chill in the refrigerator for 20 minutes.

After the designated chilling time, preheat oven to 350 degrees and remove the dough from the fridge.

Line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

Roll cookie dough into 1 ½ inch balls. Coat with granulated sugar and then into the powdered sugar. Place on lined baking sheet, at least 1 ½ – 2 inches apart from each other.

Bake for 9 to 11 minutes and allow to cool on a wire rack.

How to Bake in Batches to Make the Most of Your Baking Time

One way to handle your holiday baking is to bake in batches, then freeze and store for the big day. You can do this successfully over a couple of weeks with batch baking and batch preparing.

The biggest thing to remember is to only try a few different types of things in one day, or focus on just one type of baked good in one day. For example, you might want to bake all your quick breads in one day. Another day you can prepare all your cookie dough. Yet another time, you can bake all your fruit pies and so forth. This process makes the most of the time you have, the space you have, and your skill level.

Be Prepared

Don’t try batch baking without a plan of action. Be sure to write down your plans in advance so that you are sure you have enough time to do everything that you’ve planned. To figure out a basic time line, add up the prep time, the baking time for each oven full, and then multiply that by 1.5 to account for a little extra issues happening. Then you should be sure that you have enough time.

Get Everything Ready to Go

Your kitchen should be spotless when you start, and ensure that you have all the ingredients and appliances necessary to make each item ready to go. If you know, for example, that today you’ll be using about 10 pounds of flour, consider using a large bowl to hold the flour so you can easily spoon the flour into the measuring cup, flatten off over the bowl, without having to get into the bag over and over which usually means spillage.

Clean as You Go

Fill your sink immediately with hot soapy water so you can clean as you go. You will want to wash your mixing dishes and other utensils during the baking process so that you can use them again. There’s no point in totally destroying your kitchen as you batch bake, and you don’t have to. Set out a draining board, fill the sink with hot soapy water, and wash as you go. There are many opportunities during baking to wash a couple of dishes, and this will make the clean-up faster, and the process more organized.

All Day Batch Baking

You can set aside a day for batch baking such as a Saturday. Plan for all day baking, which usually entails 8 to 10 hours of work. Ensure that any other chores are done, including the shopping, and the kitchen is clean and ready prior to baking day. It’s important to organize your recipes with some logic behind them. For example, if you need dough to rise, start that first, so that it can be rising as you are preparing other things such as cookie dough or pie crusts. Both can be put in the refrigerator or freezer after preparation while you bake the bread, then baked after you bake the bread while the oven is still hot and ready.

Read each recipe that you plan to use and pay close attention to certain clues. For example, if an ingredient requires a cold kitchen, you’ll want to start that first. If something takes an hour to bake like banana bread, you can use that hour to mix other batter, dough, crust, filling and so forth that you can store in the refrigerator until you’re ready to bake them.

Organize the kitchen in stations. You will want a station for each type of baked good that you want to create. It’s a lot easier to lay out four pie crusts in pie tins, ready for fillings, than to do one at a time. As much as you can do for one type of thing in one run, do so. A bread making station is also essential. It needs to be a place you can freely flour the counter space, and easily clean up.

Be careful about combining batches in one recipe. If you have a cookie recipe that uses measures instead of weights, it’s better not to do them in more than one batch at a time, but you don’t need to clean the bowl between each batch that you make. Make the lightest type of batch first; for example, make sugar cookie dough before you make chocolate chip cookies, before you make peanut butter cookies. Consider the flavor, the ingredients, and everything before making the batches so that you can wash as little as possible.

The important thing about all day batch cooking is that you can choose to make only one type of baked good or you can make a number of different baked goods depending on how many people you need to feed.

Don’t try to stuff your oven too full. At most, you’ll want to cook two pies, four loaves of bread, and one large sheet of cookies at a time in one oven. Putting too many things in one oven can drastically change the temperature settings. Also, putting a dry item with a moist item in the oven at the same time can change the temperature needs. Read directions, plan ahead, and you’ll be fine.